Moneycontrol Pro Panorama | Why are auto stocks sulking despite festive cheer? 

A divergence in premium and mass-market sales negates the euphoria about the improving outlook for auto firms.

Dear Reader,

The Panorama newsletter is sent to Moneycontrol Pro subscribers on market days. It offers easy access to stories published on Moneycontrol Pro and gives a little extra by setting out a context or an event or trend that investors should keep track of. 

Paradoxically, while the traction in September auto wholesales across original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) is being attributed to the coming festive season cheer, it has failed to enthuse investors. The Nifty auto index fell, with leading OEM stocks such as Maruti Suzuki India, Hero MotoCorp, Tata Motors, Mahindra and Mahindra, Eicher Motors and Bajaj Auto trending lower (as at 1 pm in Tuesday’s trading session).

What gives?

As is usually the case, wholesale despatches from companies to the dealers expand ahead of the festive months. Companies increase their stock of vehicles in anticipation of strong retail offtake. Even so, note that September sales were only marginally higher (low single digits) across passenger vehicle (PV) and two-wheeler (2W) companies, barring commercial vehicles that recorded double-digit growth.

Furthermore, wholesales growth too is clearly from PVs, which clocked the highest-ever monthly sales in India’s auto history and surpassed the 2019 pre-pandemic high! However, dissecting PV sales shows that the euphoria is only in the sports utility vehicles (SUVs) and the multi-purpose vehicles (MPVs). Mahindra & Mahindra sold its highest-ever number of SUVs for the third consecutive month while two-thirds of Hyundai’s sales comprised these vehicles.

The country’s largest carmaker Maruti Suzuki’s sales break-up portrays a mixed bag highlighting euphoria in the premium segment car sales and pain in the lower end. This is mirrored in Maruti’s 81 per cent jump in September UV wholesales and the sharp 22 per cent drop in compact and mini car sales.

A similar trend is also seen in 2W sales. Premium category motorcycles have been posting decent sales growth while the mass-market vehicles continue to post flattish domestic sales growth or even a decline, in some months. In fact, annual 2W sales in FY2023 were still below the FY2019 levels!

Such divergence in premium and mass-market sales negates the euphoria about the improving outlook for auto firms. It also raises some pertinent questions. Is rising aspiration seeing a saturation in 2W sales that is also complicated by a desire among buyers to transition to electric vehicles? Is inflation continuing to hurt mass-market demand? Or can lower entry-level sales imply a shift by commuters to public transport systems such as metros that are improving in large cities? Are consumer patterns in the auto sector changing with buyers falling prey to the aesthetic appeal of UVs?

Whatever be the reason, the surge in premium and luxury segment vehicles will not help boost overall sales for long. OEMs at this point are clearly betting on the festive season demand to hold up sales and clear stockpiles at dealers. But one cannot ignore the headwinds from rising oil prices, food inflation that is seeming to be sticky, high interest rates that are unlikely to trend down quickly and a global slowdown that could impact the domestic job market -- all of which may dampen auto retails in the medium term.

Perhaps, the savvy investor has already sniffed the impact of some of these negatives. Note that the first fortnight of October could dampen retails as it is the inauspicious Shraddha period. This explains the jittery mood in auto counters, which might continue until the actual festive season sales give a clearer picture of the road ahead.

Investing insights from our research team

Is Q2 going to be another quarter of disappointment for Indian IT players?

Apcotex: Gradual accumulation is the way to go

Discovery Series | This company is well-positioned to ride the digital transformation wave

What else are we reading?

Just before MPC meet, manufacturing PMI shows higher selling price inflation

What do successful traders watch in markets?

The Eastern Window: New Maldives President represents a diplomatic challenge for India

How large cap IT can diverge from Accenture on order wins

China’s Real Estate Woes: How bad can things get?

Chart of the Day | Demand for bigger houses grows despite high interest rates

In The Money | Deploy Short Straddle and Strangle for sideways markets

Marketing Musings | Balancing expectations and delivery: Air India vs Vande Bharat

ESG Ratings: whose interests do they serve? (republished from the FT)

Sustaining India's growth story needs household savings to improve

Why the India Middle East Europe Economic Corridor is a poor alternative to the Suez Canal

Neobanks are not banks. Why is RBI not clamping down?

China’s Belt and Road shows the high price of Beijing’s money

How FX intervention lost its taboo in Asia

Personal Finance

IT is a contrarian bet; we have reduced our underweight on the sector: Harshad Patwardhan, CIO, Union MF

Technical Picks:  Jeera, ICICI Bank, USD-INR, Oberoi Realty, Glenmark
and Sun Pharma (These are published every trading day before markets open and can be read on the app).

Vatsala KamatMoneycontrol Pro