Moneycontrol PRO
HomeNewsPhotosBusinessPersonal FinanceSIP vs lumpsum in volatile markets: Which works better now?

SIP vs lumpsum in volatile markets: Which works better now?

With market swings becoming the norm, choosing the right investment approach is key to long-term success.

August 08, 2025 / 14:01 IST
Handling volatility with the right investment mode
1/6
Handling volatility with the right investment mode
In the turbulent market cycles, investors find themselves pitted between SIP and lumpsum investments. Both methods, however, have their advantages, and their performance can be immensely varied depending on the market cycle. In uncertain times like these, the choice, thus, is not merely based on returns but also on risk management, timing, and emotional control. Knowing how each approach performs in turbulent times can enable investors to make their choice in sync with their goals.
SIPs offer rupee cost averaging and emotional comfort
2/6
SIPs offer rupee cost averaging and emotional comfort
SIPs enable you to invest a fixed sum at a fixed frequency, for instance, monthly. This is best in turbulent market conditions since it smooths out the cost of buying units over time. During a market downturn, you end up buying more units and during a market upturn, you end up buying fewer units. The averaging behaviour smooths out the impact of volatility. More significantly, SIPs inculcate discipline in investing by eliminating the psychological factor of market timing, which is toughest during turbulent periods.
Lumpsum investments need market timing but can bring early rewards
3/6
Lumpsum investments need market timing but can bring early rewards
Lumpsum investing is the strategy of investing a large sum of money all at one point in time. While it can pay more if the markets recover after an investment, it also exposes you to the full effect of any short-term fall. A poorly timed lumpsum can result in losses at least in the short term in volatile markets. But investors with very long horizon and very high risk tolerance can benefit if they invest during a deep correction or bear cycle, purchasing inexpensive valuations.
Volatility rewards consistency over timing
4/6
Volatility rewards consistency over timing
SIPs, by their very nature, are regular and do not involve active watching of the markets. A lumpsum investment, on the other hand, requires either perfect timing or a cast-iron stomach for short-term volatility. Statistics indicate that stock market SIPs outperform lumpsum investments over the long term because of the power of compounding as well as the possibility of investing through various market cycles. That helps today, with markets across the globe being at the mercy of interest rate fluctuations, geopolitics, and sector rotation.
What type of Investor should choose which?
5/6
What type of Investor should choose which?
Your investment horizon will determine the optimal SIP vs. lumpsum choice. New or conservative investors might prefer SIPs because of their lesser emotional anguish and gradual exposure to the market's risk. Individuals with surplus liquidity, a well-defined long-term strategy, and the capacity to take shocks in the short term might prefer lumpsum — preferably in a quarter so as to minimize timing risk. A mix of both, where a part is invested upfront and the balance by SIP, is also becoming popular.
Strategy over impulse is what matters most today
6/6
Strategy over impulse is what matters most today
In volatile times, selecting strategy is more than responding to intraday market activity. SIPs provide the discipline, structure, and loss protection that is best suited for volatile markets. Lumpsum investments, although potentially lucrative, are reliant on timing ability and waiting. Regardless of your decision, having your investment process aligned with your goals, risk tolerance, and market insight is the secret to accumulating wealth in the long run.
Moneycontrol PF Team
first published: Aug 8, 2025 02:00 pm

Discover the latest Business News, Sensex, and Nifty updates. Obtain Personal Finance insights, tax queries, and expert opinions on Moneycontrol or download the Moneycontrol App to stay updated!

Advisory Alert: It has come to our attention that certain individuals are representing themselves as affiliates of Moneycontrol and soliciting funds on the false promise of assured returns on their investments. We wish to reiterate that Moneycontrol does not solicit funds from investors and neither does it promise any assured returns. In case you are approached by anyone making such claims, please write to us at grievanceofficer@nw18.com or call on 02268882347