Secured vs. unsecured personal loans: Which is right for you?

Representative image

What are secured and unsecured personal loans?

A secured personal loan is backed by collateral, in the form of property, car, or fixed deposits, and can be recovered by the lender in case you fail to repay. This collateral reduces the risk for the lender, usually resulting in lower interest rates along with larger loans. Unsecured personal loans, however, have absolutely nothing in the form of collateral. Lenders then evaluate your creditworthiness based on your income, credit score, and payment record. This makes unsecured loans more convenient in certain circumstances but typically more expensive as far as interest rates are concerned.

Interest rates and repayment terms

Secured loans will usually have lower interest rates as the lender has a backup of collateral so that they have something to fall back on. They will also tend to be longer in duration, which can keep the monthly payments small but can lead to more interest paid over the longer term. Unsecured loans generally feature higher interest rates so as to reward lenders for assuming greater risk. They generally feature short terms, which has the effect of the borrower repaying the loan over a shorter period but with larger monthly payments.

Eligibility and loan amount

Secured loans offer higher loan amounts since the collateral secures the lender in case of default. Collateral value and type, as well as your credit record, may affect eligibility. Unsecured loans, however, rely more on your credit score, steady income, and your ability to repay. Unsecured loan amounts tend to be lower than secured amounts, and approval may be tougher.

Risks and benefits

Secured loans are privileged with lower interest and greater ability to borrow extra money, but risking the loss of the security if a default occurs. Unsecured loans protect your belongings as there is no security, but with higher interest and stricter terms for borrowing. They typically take shorter time to obtain and may be a better choice for borrowers who need to borrow smaller amounts without jeopardizing their personal possessions.

Which one do you like?

Your choice should be influenced by your financial situation, repayment capacity, and risk tolerance. If you need to borrow a high amount at lower rate of interest and have collateral to pledge, a secured loan is likely to be the best bet. If you want flexibility, fast processing, and don't want to mortgage, an unsecured loan can be a viable option — if you can afford to pay the higher rate of interest.

Ultimately, the right decision is where you can balance your borrowing need, repayment ability, and risk tolerance. Giving yourself time to make the right decision will make your loan work for you, instead of overextending itself and become a burden.