Moneycontrol PRO

Review | 'Britney vs Spears' unpacks details of her conservatorship and makes a case to #FreeBritney

On September 29, 2021, a California court will decide if 39-year-old singer-songwriter Britney Spears - who has earned millions of dollars for her family - is capable of living as a free woman.

September 28, 2021 / 06:12 PM IST
Britney Spears at the 2016 Apple Music Festival in London. (Photo: Drew de F Fawkes via Wikimedia Commons 2.0)

Britney Spears at the 2016 Apple Music Festival in London. (Photo: Drew de F Fawkes via Wikimedia Commons 2.0)

Britney Spears burst on to the music scene with ‘Hit me baby one more time’ in 1997, and quickly followed it up the success of ‘Oops! I did it again!’. And unless you’ve been living under a rock, you would know that there’s a worldwide movement to #FreeBritney. The singer-songwriter has for many years been doubly locked up (figuratively) by this awful thing called a conservatorship.

Conservatorship is usually given by courts to dementia patients, geriatrics who may be unduly influenced to give away their money to people, and those who are incapable of handling their own financial matters.

When Jamie Spears, Britney Spears’ dad, applied for a temporary conservatorship, it was because she had married and divorced Kevin Federline after having two sons in two years, was driving like a bat outta hell to avoid the paparazzi and had made many friends who just looked suspicious.

When Britney suddenly went AWOL and people realised that her smile and joy had vanished, a documentary filmmaker Erin Lee Carre and a one-time Rolling Stone journalist Jenny Eliscu decided to investigate what exactly happened to Britney Spears.


This documentary exposes how Jamie Spears misused the law and took away all her freedoms. He controlled not just her finances, but also whom she could not talk to and date, and where she could go. He even dictated what phone she could have. When Britney saw that her backup dancers had iPhones and wanted one, she had to get permission from him. Her father got one only when he got a matching iPad that mirrored all her phone activity.

Her dad controlled her sexual activity, there were recordings made of her whole life, and she was prevented from getting pregnant because it would affect her concerts and they would have to get rid of another male who wanted her.

If she wanted to drive around within a beach resort on a golf cart, she’d need her father’s permission and she would have to wait 20 minutes to get it! If she wanted to drive her car alone for 30 minutes, it would take 30 people to give necessary permissions. The use of performance-enhancing drugs during concerts and when she participated as a judge in X-Factor come up in the film obviously - her father claimed that she needed his supervision because she was taking these harmful substances.

She bought her mother an estate in Louisiana, her brother a fancy apartment and her earnings paid her dad and his lawyers who kept her under their thumb, but she’s unable to deal with her money herself and needs only her father to dole out an allowance. So if she wants to buy books for her kids, she has to wait for her father to approve.

Suddenly, controlling dads like Amrish Puri in DDLJ and in all the other movies seem less toxic! In fact the closest we come to a Bollywood depiction of Jamie Spears is Anupam Kher’s Shyamlal who counts money each time Mohini dances on stage.

If Britney had to wait for her dad for 10 days to let her buy books for her kids, her dad paid about $500,000 to a ‘management’ agency run by his ‘friend’ Lou Taylor who said in 2019 that she was losing money because Britney was not performing any more. All this money was coming from Britney’s earnings! Her dad earned over $2.1 million from her tour revenues plus $16,000 salary per month from 2013-18.

The documentary is quite detailed. Case in point: look at what Britney earned:

From 2013-17, she performed 248 shows in Las Vegas: Piece of Me. 916, 184 tickets were sold and earned $137.7 million in box office revenues. That’s not all, the world tour that followed in 2018, took her to nine countries, sold 260,531 tickets and earned her $54.3 millions in ticket sales.

Why am I telling you this information from the documentary? Because her dad gave her $8,000 dollars as spending money and called it a privilege. And they kept a strict record of what she bought, where and why as well.

She tried so hard to get the courts to listen to her side. Of what she was going through and how she felt. But her father, the lawyers, the doctors just got rid of her pleas to change lawyers to represent her. The journalist who admits that she never liked Britney’s kind of music initially took an instant liking to her after meeting her. And even smuggled in application papers that would help Britney change the lawyers - the lead lawyer was earning something like $3 million.

The courts finally agreed to listen to her in June this year. And perhaps they had finally woken up to the anguish and the loneliness of her life. Perhaps they now believe that she was really being held by threats that her kids would be taken away from her, and was nothing more than a performing monkey in a ‘Circus’ for her father.

I was taken aback watching as the writer and the filmmaker calmly showed us the horrors that Britney suffered. But was most affected when she candidly admits, ‘I’m sad.’

Were the words in her song, ‘My loneliness is killing me!’ prophetic? The courts in the US will pronounce the decision on conservatorship on September 29, 2021. I fervently wish that she too is allowed to make mistakes the way you and I are allowed. That she too is free to have babies or max out her credit cards (she’s not allowed any!) like ordinary folks. That she too is allowed to go off the grid like most of us want and some manage to…

Manisha Lakhe is a poet, film critic, traveller, founder of Caferati — an online writer’s forum, hosts Mumbai’s oldest open mic, and teaches advertising, films and communication.
ISO 27001 - BSI Assurance Mark