Gaming and casinos have joined crypto trading, cigarettes and liquor in the category of activities which fall under the dreaded sin tax bracket in India. But do sin taxes work, and how?
Sin taxes are levied on alcohol and tobacco but their efficacy has been debated. The Chairman also said that GST collections are expected to bring in Rs 1.3-1.35 lakh crore on a monthly basis in the current fiscal despite pressures on the customs and excise fronts.
Indian Beverage Association, which has Pepsi India and Coca-Cola India as members, writes to Nirmala Sitharaman asking for GST relief for non-alcoholic, carbonated beverages.
If the government feels that it cannot be liberal when it comes to liquor, it needs to justify further the proposal to restrict imports. History shows that reducing availability has not reduced the consumption of liquor.
Ahead of the crucial GST council meeting on November 3, tobacco cancer survivors and researchers have urged the Council to include all tobacco products in the highest tax slab.
Rajat Rajgarhia, MD - Institutional Equities, Motilal Oswal Securities says one should analyse GST in three ways, one its positive impact on few sectors, two its negative impact on specific names and three how investors view this development.
ITC, especially, saw heavy selling and it cracked over 7 percent on news of a 'sin tax' — rate of a steep 40 percent that would be levied on select items such as tobacco products. But N Jayakumar, president of Prime Securities says regulatory headwinds have always existed for ITC
ITC shares have cracked on uncertainty on what GST could mean for tobacco products, in light of recommendations of a report by a panel headed by Chief Economic Advisor Arvind Subramanian. The report calls for a 40 percent "sin tax" for tobacco products.
Alcohol and tobacco industries will have to pay more taxes towards an additional 'sin tax' under the proposed GST structure that seeks to bring in a uniform indirect tax regime across the country.