The proposal was to allow the country to retrospectively tax cross-border transactions in which the underlying assets are located in India.
Sanofi‘s Senior Advocate And Lead Counsel Porus Kaka hopes that Vodafone conciliation would pave way for many such companies which are stuck under the retrospective amendment of I-T Act
Experts point that how the Vodafone conciliation shapes up and whether government agrees to waive of interest and the penalty related to tax liablity would be more crucial.
Legal experts say that while Vodafone conciliation could pave way for alternate dispute mechanism, the retrospective amendment in Income Tax Act introduced by Pranab Mukherjee in 2012-13 to deal with cases like Vodafone Plc must be done away with.
But CNBC-TV18‘s Aakansha Sethi reports that the government is planning to apply Section 9 of the Retrospective Amendment‘s to companies under tax scrutiny and not on cases that have already been settled.
The counsel for telecom major Vodafone, Anuradha Dutt, today told CNBC-TV18 that the company will consider a settlement with the government once they are willing to discuss the matter.
Yashwant Sinha, former finance minister and senior BJP leader, made it clear on CNBC-TV18 that the BJP will not go along on the limit of 49% in FDI.
India is back on the radar with foreign brokerages like Deutsche Bank, Morgan Stanley, BNP Paribas and JP Morgan upgrading their India rating. Falling crude prices, beaten down valuations and the promise of policy action have forced global investors to revisit the Indian markets, report CNBC-TV18's Nimesh Shah and Animesh Das.
Finance Ministry now under the Prime Minister is likely to issue a clarification circular on the retrospective amendment of section 9, reports CNBC-TV18's Aakansha Sethi quoting sources.
CNBC-TV18's economic editor Siddharth Zarabi explains that chief economic advisor Kaushik Basu‘s paper on forex manipulation and the Prime Minister‘s detailed statement to the finance ministry listing the problems that needed to be addressed in the financial sector, are clearly indicative of the change of guard and attitude in the government.
CNBC-TV18's Archana Shukla reports that global offshore funds, whose portfolios include investors who are neither FIIs or QFIs are unhappy over the retrospective amendment.
Coming out strongly in support of Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee, British parliamentarian Lord Swraj Paul told CNBC-TV18 that India was not the first country where a retrospective amendment had been introduced.
Hero MotoCorp's Sunil Munjal is not happy with the government's decision of a retrospective amendment to the IT act.
Once bitten, twice the shy, they say. But the government decided to give itself another go at Vodafone after the Supreme Court ruled in favour of the company in January in the Rs 11000 crore tax case. And again, the government has been restrained as the SC dismissed the review plea. CNBC-TV18 talks to tax experts for their first reaction.
The fate of the government’s review petition in the Rs 12,000 crore tax case with Vidafone will be decided tomorrow by the chief justice-led Supreme Court bench that had passed the order in favour of Vodafone this January. Check out the Vodafone counsel's comments.
HP Ranina, one of India's foremost corporate tax lawyers, explained that the tax rollback from 14% to 12% was a step in the right direction. He also highlighted the dilemma on the implementation of GST
Genpact's Pramod Bhasin tells CNBC-TV18 that the retrospective amendment to tax Vodafone like cases only makes doing business in India harder and more cumbersome.