Rally in oil prices not justified by fundamentals as demand recovery globally remains a major concern: Navneet Damani of MOSFL

Looking at the current rally, it seems like the current price rally is unwarranted and begs for a correction, as demand is not predicted to recover substantially until around the third quarter.

March 10, 2021 / 02:14 PM IST
Source: Reuters

Source: Reuters

WTI prices skyrocketed and traded higher for the fourth consecutive session, touching the highest levels in nearly two years after OPEC+ shocked the markets with their decision to keep production cuts largely unchanged in April. It looks like the crude complex price cycle appears to be repeating itself, with OPEC+ opting to continue restricting output rather than responding to falling inventories, rising prices and increasing backwardation. Prices got a further boost on constructive Chinese trade data released over the weekend, along with news that the $1.9 trillion US stimulus package was passed by the Senate.

Major Banks upgraded price forecasts, with some calls for oil reaching north of $100 next year. Markets cheered the fact that OPEC is not worried about tightening markets, nor higher prices which will bring shale players back in the markets. The most surprising fact was Saudi’s intention to extend its voluntary oil output cut of 1 million bpd and would decide in coming months when to gradually phase it out. This caught investors by surprise and led some to revise upwards their price forecasts. The Saudis have raised prices for its crude for shipment to Asia and the US next month after OPEC+ extended oil supply constraints, pointing to a tightening physical market.

On the premium front, the geopolitical premium is once again in picture after news that Iranian-backed Houthi rebels attacked a Saudi oil export facility over the weekend. The target was in fact, the Ras Tanura export facility, which is the world’s largest export facility, capable of shipping around 6.5 million barrels per day of crude oil, and with a storage capacity of around 33 million barrels.

All of Saudi Arabia's key crude oil grades -- mainly Arab Heavy, Arab Medium, Arab Light and Arab Extra Light -- load from here along with condensate and refined products. Saudi’s have however reported no damage to any facility or any disruption. The attack followed a missile launch by Houthis rebels on Saudi Aramco facilities at Jeddah on March 4th. The geopolitical premium of disruption is expected to remain as Iran is expected to continue the ramp up attacks through proxies as a low cost way to bleed Saudi Arabia.

The whole sentiment of the paper market has turned bullish, but physical markets have failed to show any signs of tightness. Oil demand still appears pretty weak. Investors appear to be looking further forward to expectations for a strong demand recovery over the second half of this year. However, if these stronger demand expectations don’t move as per expectations then markets can see a rafter downward correction.


OPEC leaders are somewhere gambling on the prospects of the future of Shale as consolidation looks like an immediate future for players in the US on account of needing to give back return to shareholders in place of more capital expenditure to drill more oil. Saudi Arabia is somewhere overconfident about shale as data shows that the number of rigs drilling for oil in the United States has already risen to 309, up from a low of just 172 last August, though it is still well below 678 at the same point last year.

If players once again start increasing production in shale, then the whole OPEC+ dynamics will once again be under question. In all this enthusiasm, higher prices are likely to increase strain within OPEC+ as some members like UAE, Russia and Iraq will want to pump more to relieve under-pressure economies. The group’s next meeting is scheduled for April 1 to discuss production levels for May.

On the inventory front, Energy Information Administration reported crude oil inventory build of 21.6 million barrels which was in stark contrast to the estimated 7.356-MB build reported by API and expectations of an inventory draw of 1.85 million barrels. . Gasoline inventories fell by 13.6 MB, the most since 1990 whilst distillate stocks dropped by the largest margin since 2003, down by 9.7 million barrels. Crude inventories saw a record rise by 21.6 MB. These large decreases were expected as refinery operations in the Gulf Coast were heavily affected by the storm in Texas in Feb, with the enormous product draw more than offsetting the record crude build.

US crude oil production, meanwhile, is ticking up, but remains well below pre-pandemic levels. The EIA reported crude production in the week averaged 10.0 million barrels per day, an increase of 300,000 barrels per day from the prior week but 3.1 million barrels per day lower year-on-year.


Looking at the current rally, it seems like the current price rally is unwarranted and begs for a correction, as demand is not predicted to recover substantially until around the third quarter. The current rally is not justified by oil market fundamentals as demand recovery globally remains a major question. There are many risks as in a higher price environment, OPEC+ is enjoying the continued restricting output below its potential level to enjoy a temporary windfall by way of higher prices.

Disclaimer: The views and investment tips expressed by investment expert on Moneycontrol.com are his own and not that of the website or its management. Moneycontrol.com advises users to check with certified experts before taking any investment decisions.
Navneet Damani is the VP – Commodity Research at Motilal Oswal Financial Services.
first published: Mar 10, 2021 02:12 pm

stay updated

Get Daily News on your Browser