Moneycontrol Be a Pro
Get App
you are here: HomeNewsIndia
Last Updated : Apr 28, 2019 04:24 PM IST | Source:

Moneycontrol on the Road: What's in a name? Ask Pragya Thakur and Pragya Thakur in Bhopal

This initiative is meant to understand the pulse of local businesses and their assessment of government policies

M Saraswathy @maamitalks

India is voting to elect its 17th Lok Sabha. Three phases of polling have been held while four are still to go. The results are scheduled to be declared on May 23.

Moneycontrol correspondent M Saraswathy is on a 1,300-km journey via road from Mumbai to Bhopal via Daman, Surat, Ahmedabad, Bhilwara, Guna and Itarsi. The idea behind this initiative is to understand the pulse of the local businesses and their assessment of government policies. It is a report card through the eyes of local entrepreneurs and farm owners.

This is a diary of her experiences as she traverses through different regions:


Day 7 - April 28

4.21 pm: The statements made by BJP's Fatima Rasool Siddiqui has ruffled quite a lot of feathers within the party high command. Siddiqui who had joined the BJP last year had recently refused to campaign for 'Sadhvi' Pragya Singh Thakur saying that she has hurt the sentiments of the Muslims across the country.

Siddiqui has also demanded that Sadhvi Pragya should apologise for her remarks made on the Babri Masjid demolition and only then she would support her.

Senior leaders within BJP's Madhya Pradesh unit are now consulting the Delhi headquarters team to decide on the course of action on this issue. The idea is to resolve the situation immediately to avoid further embarrassment for the party.

2.43 pm: At a time when Congress leader Digvijaya Singh has pitched for a developed and self-reliant Bhopal, social activists are miffed at the exclusion of special benefits for the 1984 Bhopal gas tragedy victims' families.

Many families do not have a source of livelihood while others face serious health issues. Rabiya Banu, a social rights activist said that government funding or job opportunities as well as subsidised medical care for the families is a must.

Only a handful of individuals are eligible for the Rs 5 lakh health insurance under the Pradhan Mantri Jan Arogya Yojana and many others do not get affordable medical facilities. With this, these families are pinning hopes on local leaders to pay heed to their demand.

09.05 am: As the election campaign is in full force in Bhopal, a big cause of concern for some voters is that the BJP is still finalising its manifesto there.

Congress, through its Bhopal candidate Digvijaya Singh, has presented a vision of 'Samriddh Bhopal, Samarth Bhopal' that talks about better jobs, connectivity, development of technology through IT hubs, conservation of water bodies, among others.

Meanwhile, the BJP is in talks with party leaders to zero down on the points that can be part of the vision document. Pragya Singh Thakur, who is BJP's candidate from Madhya Pradesh' capital is said to be visiting local families in the district to understand their individual concerns and what solutions they seek. As Bhopal goes for voting on May 12, there is a paucity of time in releasing a manifesto for this constituency.

Day 6 - April 27

04.21 pm: The religious divide in the state of Bhopal is clearly visible with BJP vying for the 70 percent Hindu voters of the Lok Sabha constituency and Congress pinning hopes on the Muslims that constitute 30 percent. BJP agenda is to woo the Hindus and encourage them to cast their votes on the polling day on May 12.

Senior BJP leaders are unfazed by the Assembly poll debacle in Madhya Pradesh. The consensus among party members in the state is that Bhopal remains a saffron seat and will continue to be one. The only issue under watch is by how many votes will Pragya Singh Thakur of the BJP will defeat Digvijay Singh of the Congress. The minimum estimate is 1-1.5 lakh vote margin while the maximum margin could touch 3 lakh, said BJP. Meanwhile, Congress is hoping to tilt liberal Hindus towards their side.

02.09 pm: Murder for water was one of the common issues in parts of Bhopal. Local residents would often lock their water tanks placed outside their houses. Attacks on one other to get a few litres of water for daily use were common. Residents said that even neighbours turned foes and would plainly refuse to share their water that was procurred from private tankers. However, the past two to three years have changed the situation with the Narmada water project. Now, water is available more freely and in sufficient quantity.

11.00 am: It was a case of mistaken identity handled tactfully by BJP's Bhopal Lok Sabha contestant Pragya Singh Thakur also referred to as 'Sadhvi' Pragya. Another lady by the name of Pragya Thakur had planned to contest from the same seat as an independent candidate. Party insiders said that Sadhvi Pragya personally went and met her namesake, requesting her to not contest elections. Immediately after her visit, the other Pragya took back her nomination and has declined to fight the elections in 2019. The main objective for dissuading her was to ensure that votes do not get divided between the two Pragya Thakurs and BJP was of the view that local voters would get confused by the name and mistakenly vote for the independent candidate this elections.

Day 5 - April 26

12.54 pm: While the new government in Madhya Pradesh under chief minister Kamal Nath announced a Rs 50,000 crore farm loan waiver in the state, implementation issues are still to be ironed out. After the scheme was launched in January 2019, there was a case of a farmer receiving Rs 13 waiver instead of Rs 24,000. After this was reported, the MP government has sprung into action to ensure that small farmers with loans up to Rs 2 lakh get the complete benefit of the scheme. The scheme, titled, Jan Kisan Rin Mukti Yojana, could prove to a vote-puller during the Lok Sabha Elections 2019. The Congress government went ahead with this scheme that was a part of the Assembly poll promise, despite stiff opposition from BJP which called it economically unviable.

08.35 am: At Guna in Madhya Pradesh, it is a poll fight between former party colleagues. Incumbent Jyotiraditya Scindia from Congress and KP Yadav from the BJP are contesting from the Guna constituency. Interestingly, Yadav joined BJP last year from INC. Party insiders said he felt neglected and that his work was not acknowledged by Congress leaders. But now that he has been pitted against Scindia, it will make some impact. Yadav used to be a confidante of Scindia and is well aware of his strengths and weaknesses. While Scindia still remains the people's favourite in Guna, KP Yadav could make a slight dent in this scenario since he could influence the sizeable Yadav community in this region to vote for BJP.

Day 4 - April 25

5.25 pm: As the Chambal Bhilwara Water Supply Project is gaining momentum, both Congress ans BJP claim it to be their pet project.

In 2013, Sonia Gandhi had laid the foundation stone for this project that looked into the issues of the quality and quantity problem of water in Bhilwara district.

However, BJP workers claim that it was their party who took all the concrete steps to institutionalise this process and ensure proper timelines for the project. Clear water pump house, clear water system, storage system & distribution network for the Bhilwara town are proposed as part of the project design to be implemented by 2030. Meanwhile, both parties are milking this scheme to their full advantage in their poll campaigns.

12.33 pm: A local political unit, Bharatiya Tribal Party (BTP), has become a pain point for both BJP and the Congress in this election.

The party that won two seats in the Assembly elections in 2018 and is now fielding five candidates from Jaipur, Jodhpur and Udaipur (three). BTP was originally formed in Gujarat in 2017 and had also won two seats in the 2017 Gujarat Assembly elections.

Local leaders of both Congress and BJP, in Rajasthan, are of the view that BTP will find favour among the local Bhils and other tribal communities. Both parties are viewing BTP as a threat and will try to get them to possible ally after the election.

8.53 am: While Congress may have won the Assembly election in Rajasthan, it is going to be a tough fit in places like Bhilwara which is a part of the Mewar region. Political analysts say that those who win this region win the state as well.

With BJP trying to charm the locals using the popularity of PM Modi, Congress is focusing on local issues. Be it farmers' minimum wages, water scarcity or tribal welfare, Congress wants to bring those issues to the forefront in this election.

Infighting among BJP workers after the Assembly polls debacle is being used as a full advantage by Congress. A state where caste dominates individual voting decisions, it is to be seen who wins the general election battle.

Day 3 - April 24

5.13 pm: It is a battle against water scarcity as soon as you reach the entry point to Rajasthan. With scarce rainfall and drying rivers, the state is witnessing a heat wave since the last two weeks. Water is a precious commodity across rural and urban Rajasthan.

water saras

Urban areas are notorious for the tanker mafia, who are known to charge exorbitant rates from those in need. Efforts from local NGOs to create awareness about water conservation have fallen on deaf ears. While there are plans to revive the process to dig deeper to find the lost river Saraswati and a potential blessing for the parched state, the wealthy can still afford to buy water from private parties. It is those who belong to the lower economic strata who are fighting a tough battle for water supply.

1.22 pm: Amidst the Clean Ganga mission, clamour to clean the Narmada river is also growing. Ahmedabad-based Bhavik Desai and a handful of denim traders have sought a similar funding proposal for the Narmada as well. While Desai admits that the Narmada is cleaner than the Ganga, there is a paucity of funds to keep it clean on a continuous basis.

"We could start from Rs 50 crore a year and then increase/decrease the amount on the basis of the cleanliness of the river," he added. This group is planning to send a detailed campaign once the new government is sworn into power in May. He is of the belief that more than the inter-linking of rivers, cleaning all the holy rivers is of utmost importance.

8.10 am: The Goods and Services Tax (GST) regime, that was introduced to simplify the system of indirect taxes in the country, is still taking time to stabilise in regions in Ahmedabad.

Gujarat missed the 14 percent targeted growth in GST collections by almost Rs 7,000 crore and has sought central government assistance to meet the gap.

This is primarily due to a shortfall in business revenues and margins by large industries like the denim market in Ahmedabad that is facing huge cost pressures. Some family units have pivoted to other apparels like rayon and polyester while others have shrunk business operations.

Day 2 - April 23

5.14 pm: With only 52.59 percent voter turnout in Surat till 5 pm as per the Election Commission data, several traders have started getting calls from local party offices asking them to vote if they haven't. Diamond traders, in particular, were asked to keep their business units closed on April 23 to ensure that all local employees are given a chance to cast their votes.

Unlike other states, Surat has most votes cast between 7 am and 10 am with first preference being given to senior citizens and differently abled followed by pregnant women. In urban Surat, voters prefer the 7 am slot because it is cooler and finding a parking spot outside polling booths is easier — unlike states like Maharashtra (especially Mumbai) that restrict any vehicle from being in a 100-metre vicinity of any polling booth. "We officially have such rules too. But what can we do? If we stop cars, people will not even come to vote," says a security officer stationed outside a polling booth near Surat railway station.

1.03 pm: While the whole country swallowed the goods and services tax as a bitter-sweet pill, a family of Marwadi traders settled in Surat thinks otherwise. With GST, they claim that they are able to spot fraud and from which level in the buyer value-chain it originates from. Since all levels of the transaction have been made paper-less, this has aided them in curbing fraud at the base itself. Earlier, they claimed that small frauds of Rs 2-5 crore went unnoticed. That is no longer the case, they added. However, the short-term pain of GST will last for another 6-8 months and these traders are ready to bear it. "We at least know Darshana Jardosh and the groundwork she has done for the city. The other candidate is barely seen," claims Haribhai Damania, a textile store owner.

9.57 am: While BJP youth have set up stalls across Surat on the poll day, similar ones of INC were conspicuous by their absence. BJP's incumbent candidate Darshana Jardosh is contesting against Ashok Patel of the Congress. Locals state that Surat has traditionally been a BJP bastion, though there is some tilt towards the Congress after the GST was introduced. From nil GST, textile traders have to pay between 5-12% GST based on the type of the goods sold.

8.31 am: The absence of star campaigners has been a bit of a letdown in the Lok Sabha elections 2019 in Surat. Traders across the city have been urged by the industry association to go out and vote in large numbers. In the absence of big rallies or major Gujarati and Bollywood stars taking part in the campaign this year means that traders would use this day as an extended weekend to go out for a short vacation.

However, both Congress and BJP party workers have personally met Surat textile and diamond traders over the past 2-3 weeks asking them to exercise their democratic right.

7.21 am: Ahead of the Lok Sabha elections 2019 in Surat, hotels across the city are doing brisk business. With election officials and police personnel on election duty checking into such facilities in large numbers, hotels are also making use of this opportunity. Average room rates are up by 20-25 percent, said a hotel owner on the Surat Railway Station Road that houses multiple polling stations.

Similarly, the handful of hotels on the textile market road too have been booked out almost one month before. This is despite the fact that the average room rent is Rs 3,800 onwards in 3-star hotels. April is generally considered a lean season because those from neighbouring areas of Gujarat go on religious tours to places like Dwarka or on leisure trips to locations like Goa and Shimla.

Day 1 - April 22

4.29 pm: Daman, which is often frequented by Gujaratis for the availability of liquor, is still reeling under the impact of the Supreme Court ban on alcohol sale along highways. While the ban was revoked, local liquor shop owners said there is frequent checks by traffic police and heavy fines are imposed on those in possession of more than one bottle of hard liquor. "If you want tourism to grow, alcohol is an important attraction point. On one hand, asking for bribes to allow carriage of liquor is not uncommon. On the other, tourists are also manhandled and forced to pay money to police personnel," said Amitesh Hari, owner of Harinam Wines.

Also Read | Want a saree on demonetisation? Here's how PM Modi's political decisions influenced a Surat trader

12.42 pm: At first glance, Daman — touted as a tourist destination — seems to be missing one important sanitation facility: public toilets. Be it the shopping areas or the roads to the beach, toilets are either missing or non-functional. While the Daman & Diu waste management and sanitation policy 2018 stated that the Union Territory has been declared open-defecation free, the reverse is true.

A public toilet in Daman

Not only does the beach front have inadequate toilet facilities, a problem especially for female tourists, the few constructed have been poorly maintained. Government figures show that 675 and 3,003 toilets have been constructed in urban and rural Daman respectively, under the Swachh Bharat Mission. At least 20 percent of those are unsanitory. The actual figures of unusable toilets, locals state, are 40-45 percent of these units.

9.48 am: Poll-bound Daman wears a deserted look with most bars shut till 6 pm on April 23. The Union Territory goes to polls on Tuesday. While incumbent MP Lalubhai Patel has been nominated by the BJP for the third time in a row, local party workers said they were unhappy over other faces not being given a chance. A local party worker said the fight will be a close call this year, with Congress re-fielding Ketan Patel and BSP fielding Bhavesh Patel. Infrastructure development has been a key area of focus in this region, though local businessmen have opposed widening of roads that will lead to demolition of roadside eateries and wine shops.

The Great Diwali Discount!
Unlock 75% more savings this festive season. Get Moneycontrol Pro for a year for Rs 289 only.
Coupon code: DIWALI. Offer valid till 10th November, 2019 .
First Published on Apr 28, 2019 09:05 am
NULL int(1)
Follow us on
Available On
PCI DSS Compliant