US set to overhaul H-1B lottery system: Why Indians could feel the biggest impact | Explained

Representational Image

The US will replace its random H-1B visa lottery with a weighted system favoring higher-paid, higher-skilled workers from February 2026, impacting many Indian professionals. Critics say wage-based selection may not accurately reflect skill or job specialization.

Did our AI summary help?

The United States is set to fundamentally change how H-1B visas are allocated, replacing the long-standing random lottery system with a new weighted selection model that prioritises higher-paid and ostensibly higher-skilled workers.

The change, announced by the US Department of Homeland Security, will take effect from February 27, 2026, and could significantly alter the prospects of thousands of Indian professionals who dominate the H-1B ecosystem.

The move comes amid a broader immigration crackdown under the Donald Trump administration that has targeted both legal and illegal migration, including tighter visa scrutiny and sharply higher costs for employers.

What is the H-1B visa and why is it changing?

The H-1B visa allows US companies to hire foreign workers in specialised occupations. Every year, 65,000 visas are issued under the general quota, along with an additional 20,000 visas reserved for applicants with advanced degrees from US institutions.

Demand far outstrips supply, which is why the US Citizenship and Immigration Services runs a lottery to select beneficiaries. Indians account for roughly 70 to 75 percent of all H-1B visas issued annually.

Until now, selection was purely random.

That will no longer be the case.

“The new rule replaces the random lottery for selecting visa recipients with a process that gives greater weight to those with higher skills,” the DHS said. “Pure randomisation does not serve the ends of the H-1B programme.”

How will the new weighted lottery work?

Under the revised system, applicants will be entered into the lottery based on wage levels, which are divided into four categories.

Registrations for wage level IV will be entered into the lottery four times, level III three times, level II twice, and level I once. Each applicant will still count only once towards the annual cap, but higher wages will significantly improve selection odds.

Data cited by the US government show that nearly 90 percent of H-1B applications by international students fall under wage levels I and II, which are typically entry-level or early-career roles. Wage level IV is classified as the highest and generally includes workers with management or supervisory responsibilities.

“This weighted selection process will generally favour the allocation of H-1B visas to higher-skilled and higher-paid aliens, while maintaining the opportunity for employers to secure H-1B workers at all wage levels,” the DHS said in its final rule.

Why is Washington making this change now?

US authorities argue that the existing lottery system has been exploited by employers to hire cheaper foreign labour at the expense of American workers.

“The existing random selection process of H-1B registrations was exploited and abused by US employers who were primarily seeking to import foreign workers at lower wages than they would pay American workers,” said Matthew Tragesser, a spokesperson for US Citizenship and Immigration Services.

The DHS insists that the changes do not eliminate access to H-1B visas for lower-wage roles but are designed to discourage misuse.

The rule is also aligned with other recent policy shifts, including a Presidential Proclamation requiring employers to pay an additional $100,000 per visa as a condition of eligibility.

What else is changing for employers and applicants?

The overhaul extends beyond the lottery itself.

Employers will now be required to submit wage levels, job classification codes, and work locations at the registration stage. Supporting documents must be submitted during the petition phase to justify these claims.

USCIS has also been granted broader authority to deny or revoke petitions if it finds that companies are manipulating wages, roles, or locations to improve lottery chances.

According to the DHS, these measures are intended to strengthen oversight and restore credibility to the programme.

“The new weighted selection will better serve Congress’ intent for the H-1B programme and strengthen America’s competitiveness by incentivising American employers to petition for higher-paid, higher-skilled foreign workers,” Tragesser said.

Will the changes hurt Indian professionals?

The impact on Indians is expected to be significant.

Indian nationals dominate the H-1B system, particularly in the technology and IT services sectors. Companies such as Amazon, Tata Consultancy Services, Infosys, Wipro, Microsoft, Apple and Google are among the biggest users of the visa programme.

Amazon alone received 10,000 H-1B visas this year, the highest for any single company. California continues to host the largest concentration of H-1B workers.

However, many of these roles are entry-level or mid-level positions, which typically fall under wage levels I and II. The new system heavily favours senior and specialised roles with higher salaries, potentially squeezing out younger professionals and recent graduates.

Smaller companies and outsourcing firms could also be forced to rethink their US hiring strategies.

Why some experts are sceptical

Despite the government’s framing, critics argue that wage levels do not always accurately reflect skill.

“Unfortunately, it will still be a lottery, and weighted by seniority instead of higher-skilled occupations,” said Jeremy Neufeld, Immigration Policy Director at the Institute of Progress, as quoted by The Times of India.

He pointed out anomalies in how wage levels are classified, arguing that less critical jobs could gain an advantage over genuinely specialised roles due to regional pay structures.

According to Neufeld, an acupuncturist or HR specialist in certain regions could enjoy better odds than a paediatric surgeon or aerospace engineer elsewhere, despite the latter roles being more specialised.

The bigger picture

The H-1B overhaul reflects Washington’s growing discomfort with how the visa programme has evolved, particularly its use by large firms to fill lower-cost positions.

For Indian professionals, especially younger workers and international students, the new rules could make the path to working in the US narrower and more uncertain.

For employers, the changes signal a tougher compliance environment and higher costs.

While the DHS maintains that the system remains open to all wage levels, the shift away from pure chance means the era of equal lottery odds is coming to an end.