Rare earth magnet incentive lifts GMDC, other mineral stocks, yet Indian market lacks a true rare-earth play

A powerful policy-driven rally has sent mineral stocks higher this week, but analysts warn that investors should not read too much into the rare-earth theme when it comes to Gujarat Mineral Development Corporation (GMDC) or other listed miners. The surge comes as the government prepares a major incentive scheme for rare earth permanent magnet (REPM) manufacturing, a development that has spurred enthusiasm across the broader materials space.

GMDC stock has posted sharp gains over the past two sessions, driven largely by optimism around the Cabinet’s expected approval of a Rs 7,300-crore incentive programme. However, market experts say that neither GMDC nor any other domestic miner is positioned to benefit meaningfully from the rare-earth magnet value chain at this stage, and that the current rally is running ahead of business fundamentals.

Market rally collides with supply and quality constraints

Veteran market expert Dipan Mehta said on Wednesday that GMDC’s long-discussed efforts to move from lignite and coal into higher-value minerals have not translated into a viable rare-earth business. In an interview with CNBC TV18, he said that GMDC has not sustainably increased volumes over the years and argued that investors “just cannot buy GMDC on the basis that India intends to manufacture more rare earths or do more mining.”

He added that India does not yet have a listed company that offers genuine exposure to the rare-earth magnet investment theme, saying there is “no play on rare earths” of meaningful scale.

• Also read | How did China come to dominate the rare-earth trade? Production jumped ninefold in three decades

Oxide shortfall may limit the rare-earth opportunity

Underlying constraints in the domestic ecosystem reinforce that caution. India currently has only one entity - IREL under the Department of Atomic Energy - that mines rare-earth elements and refines them into rare-earth oxides. Even that supply is limited.

In recent discussions with the Ministry of Heavy Industries, IREL reportedly informed the government that it can supply no more than 500 tonnes of oxides annually. To produce the 6,000 tonnes of REPMs targeted under the proposed incentive scheme, manufacturers would require about 1,500 tonnes of rare-earth oxides each year. This leaves a deficit of 1,000 tonnes that would still need to be imported, indicating that domestic mining companies like GMDC are not positioned to benefit from the scheme in the near term.

Sona BLW Precision Forgings (Sona Comstar) remains among the few listed companies with a direct operational connection to rare-earth magnets, as India’s largest importer of these components. Yet even Sona Comstar is at an early stage, still evaluating whether domestic magnet manufacturing is viable under the forthcoming incentive scheme.

Local rare earth production may be years away

Managing Director Vivek Vikram Singh has repeatedly stressed that it will take at least two to three years to establish meaningful magnet-making capacity in India. He has also raised concerns about the quality of magnets likely to be produced locally unless proper testing infrastructure is created. During stakeholder meetings, Singh said that India’s available rare-earth material is of lower grade, requiring additional refining steps that would raise costs.

• Also read | Nifty, Sensex at fresh record highs: Here are 4 factors that led market to new peak after 14 months

He has been equally vocal about global supply risks. With 94 percent of rare-earth magnet supply concentrated in a single country, he has compared the situation to the semiconductor industry’s dependence on Taiwan. Sona Comstar is evaluating the incentive scheme but has not yet committed investment, saying its decision will depend on the fine print of the government package and the viability of domestic production.

These structural realities mean that incentives alone cannot bridge the gap between policy ambition and operational capacity. India’s rare-earth value chain -- from mining and refining to alloying and magnet manufacturing -- remains fragmented and significantly undersupplied. For GMDC and other miners, this translates into limited near-term upside from the magnet push, regardless of market sentiment.

GMDC’s recent rally reflects enthusiasm around a high-visibility policy announcement rather than a material change in its business prospects. Until India addresses its oxide shortfall, quality and refining limitations, and the absence of an integrated manufacturing ecosystem, GMDC and other mineral stocks may not be treated as rare-earth investment proxies. The momentum in share prices is strong, but the investable rare-earth opportunity may be several years away.

---

Disclaimer: The views and investment tips expressed by experts on Moneycontrol are their own and not those of the website or its management. Moneycontrol advises users to check with certified experts before taking any investment decisions.