Moneycontrol Pro Panorama | Is SEBI overregulating? Traders warn of risks to India’s derivatives market

SEBI's objective may be to reduce excessive short-term speculation in high-frequency options trading.

Dear Reader,

The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) appears to be taking steps that may reshape the structure of the options market in the country. Regarded as one of the largest derivatives markets globally, the Indian options segment is now facing potential changes due to recent regulatory proposals.

SEBI is reportedly considering further changes to the frequency of options expirations. Having already shifted from daily expirations to twice weekly (one per exchange), there is speculation that this could be further reduced to bi-weekly expirations.

This proposed change could have a notable impact on the trading and broking community, particularly those who rely on frequent expirations for their strategies. SEBI's objective may be to reduce excessive short-term speculation in high-frequency options trading.

One outcome of the current weekly expiration cycle has been the rapid development of algorithmic trading in India. Advanced technology platforms have emerged, and many training institutes now educate traders in quantitative strategies, helping to foster careers both domestically and internationally, particularly for engineering and MBA graduates.

This field has benefited significantly from the frequency of expiration-day trading, which creates predictable volatility and trading opportunities. However, the rise of algorithmic trading and high-frequency strategies has also raised concerns globally about fairness, market manipulation, and accessibility — issues that regulators like SEBI are increasingly attentive to.

While some criticisms — such as those raised by the Jane Street episode — point to lapses in oversight,  SEBI’s efforts may be an attempt to rectify systemic issues, even if these steps affect some well-intentioned traders.

SEBI has cited data suggesting that a significant portion of options traders incur losses — reportedly up to 95%. While such statistics are not unusual in leveraged financial markets globally, they do raise valid concerns about retail investor education and the risks of speculative trading.

A reduction in expiration days may affect certain strategies employed by traders, particularly those focused on intraday and short-term trading. However, it may also prompt a shift towards longer-term, potentially more stable approaches.

SEBI has recently promoted greater participation in the cash segment. However, some traders point out that past restrictions on broker leverage for retail clients have already reduced their trading capacity in that space.

The logic behind SEBI's policy has sparked debate. While it seeks to limit speculative activity in the options segment, similar behaviour may still be prevalent in other areas of the market.

There is a possibility that some traders may explore alternative markets such as forex platforms if they perceive domestic regulations to be overly restrictive or misaligned with their strategies. However, this migration also carries risks, as these platforms may offer less regulatory oversight and weaker investor protections compared to domestic exchanges.

Until SEBI and its advisors acknowledge that trading is inherently a zero-sum game, where some will inevitably lose, their actions may inadvertently harm the market further.

In conclusion, SEBI’s proposed reforms to the options market highlight the delicate balance between regulation and innovation. While the regulator’s concerns about retail losses and market stability are valid, the broader impact on trader livelihoods, technological advancement, and India’s growing financial ecosystem cannot be overlooked. A more measured approach — one that addresses malpractices without stifling legitimate trading activity — may better serve both investor protection and market development. As the debate continues, it’s essential for policy decisions to consider the long-term health and competitiveness of India’s financial markets. 

Investing insights from our research team

Will VIP be able to overcome the rough patch with the change in ownership?

Discovery Series: Jyoti CNC Automation – An emerging leader in precision machine tools

Carysil: Cautiously optimistic

What else are we reading? 

Why the 4% inflation target must stay

Chart of the Day: Fund managers take shelter in China

Fed chair's dovish turn sparks rally, but reveals deeper economic worries

Japan's Big Pivot: Why Modi's visit marks a new chapter in Asian partnerships

Focus turns to execution at Hindustan Aeronautics as orders pour in

Personal Finance: How to put PE ratio to use in analysing stocks

Mohamed El-Erian: Jay Powell’s risk-averse stance at Jackson Hole missed an opportunity (republished from the FT)

Why bitcoin treasury companies are a fool’s paradise (republished from the FT)

Faced with urea and fertiliser shortages again, is it time to reimagine our agrarian system?

Sky Grab: China's ambitious plans to dominate the orbital internet race

Mumbai rains, airplane crashes, stock crashes: How recency bias destroys wealth

Pujara - The last pure test batsman

Lord Swraj Paul, an irrepressible personality with a chequered career

US’ targeting of Baloch Liberation Army shows its layered approach to Pakistan and China

Markets

India-focused funds see highest redemptions since January as FPI outflows pick up pace

Technical Picks: NH, ZYDUSLIFE, MANAPPURAM, ICICIBANK, WOCKPHARMA

Shishir Asthana Moneycontrol Pro