Home » News » Personal Finance»Fixed Income - Bank Deposits
Jan 15, 2013, 03.28 PM | Source: Moneycontrol.com

Which is a better investment? Tax-Free Bonds or FDs

Investors are often seen confused when it comes to choosing between Tax free Bonds and Fixed Deposits. Choosing one between the two largely depends on investor’s goal as pros and cons exist in both the products. Read this space to know what factors differentiate these two fixed income instruments to take better investment decision.

IIFCL is the latest company to come up with tax-free bonds, and with a 20-year option they have made people think about them who would have other wise ignored tax-free bonds.

This is because while their utility for residents in the 30% tax bracket is quite clear, it isn’t so clear whether others who don’t have fall under the 30% tax bracket should also opt for them or should they just choose fixed deposits instead.

NRIs are one segment of the population in whose case this comparison becomes applicable because they can access NRE Fixed Deposits, which are also tax-free for them, and in general have a higher interest rate than tax-free bonds. 

Residents who are under the taxable income limit or pay 10% taxes are also one segment that has to make this decision.

Let’s look at some factors that you must consider while choosing between tax-free bonds and fixed deposits.

1. Interest Rates: The first factor is of course interest rate, and in this respect, fixed deposits have a clear edge on tax-free bonds because currently most banks give a higher rate on fixed deposits when you compare that with a tax-free bond of similar maturity.

2. Benefit of compounding: This is another area where fixed deposits score over tax free bonds because tax free bonds pay out interest every year and there is no benefit of compounding whereas in fixed deposits your interest usually gets compounded every quarter.


3. Reinvestment risk: Once again, fixed deposits do better than tax-free bonds because you have the option of reinvesting interest income back in the fixed deposit at the same rate whereas you are paid out interest annually in the case of tax free bonds, and you have to take care of investing the interest income yourself. This is a big factor if you don’t need the interest income every year and would much rather have a bigger lump sum amount at the end.

For example, a 9.00% fixed deposit for Rs. 1 lakh that compounds quarterly for 10 years will yield Rs. 2,43,518 at the end of 10 years whereas if you put the same amount in a tax free bond that gives out 7.69% interest like IIFCL then your interest earned in the ten years would be Rs. 76,900 and you will get Rs. 1,00,000 back at maturity.

This of course ignores what you do with the annual interest, and the time value of money, but for people who would much rather get a bigger lump sum at the end of the tenure because they don’t have a near term need for money, this is an important factor to consider.

4. Liquidity: I feel that as far as liquidity is concerned, tax-free bonds have a slight edge over fixed deposits. If you want to break your fixed deposit early then you have to pay a certain penalty in the form of a reduced interest rate but in the case of tax-free bonds you can sell them in the secondary market and if interest rates go down then the bonds will trade up. 

This market is not all that well developed right now, and you may face issues with selling a large amount of bonds, or if rates go up then you may have to sell your bonds at a discount but as far as the present situation is concerned, tax free bonds do seem to have an edge on bank fixed deposits as far as liquidity is concerned.

5. Tenure: IIFCL has come out with a 20-year bond, which has the longest maturity of any tax-free bond so far and gives you the opportunity to lock in a rate of 7.90% for 20 years. Banks don’t offer a fixed deposit of more than 10 years, and if you wanted to lock in to this rate for a very long time like 20 years then this tax-free bond is the way to go for you.

6. Capital Appreciation: Since bonds list on the market, and move in an inverse direction with respect to interest rates (they go up when interest rates go down and vice versa) there is a good chance that some of these bonds will give appreciate and give you capital gains when interest rates go down. The assumption of course is that we have seen the worst of the high interest rate scenario and rates will go down in the future from the levels we currently see.

Conclusion

There are pros and cons to both products and it largely depends on what you’re trying to do. If you have need for annual interest then the tax free bonds are probably better because they will pay you annually and you can sell them early to get capital gains if they appreciate.

On the other hand, if you want a bigger lump sum then fixed deposits are probably better as they allow you to build a bigger corpus and free your mind of reinvesting the interest income every year.

ADS BY GOOGLE

Ask the Experts

Get your Personal Finance queries answered

  • Q

    If I put Rs 2 lakh in PPF, how much tax rebate I will get?

    A

    As per the existing guidelines and rules a person cannot deposit more than 1.5 lacs in one PPF account. However you can deposit money in the...

  • Q

    Interest rates are going to go down. And all my fixed deposits will be maturing next year. I will have to renew my fixed deposits next year at lower rate of interest. What is the way out?

    A

    Interest rates keep fluctuating due to various micro- and macro- economic factors. There is never an ideal rate of interest. In a high inter...

  • Q

    I want to buy online term life insuance plan. Which is the best one? Should I go for single premium or regular premium policy?

    A

    Single premium term insurance policies don?t make much sense. Why pay such a large amount at one go when you have the option of paying in sm...

  • Q

    I want to invest some money with at least ten years view. I dont want share market risk. Can I invest in NSC? Is there any other investment option?

    A

    NSC or National Savings Certificate is a safe investment scheme offered by the Central Government. It is an ideal option for investors with ...

  • Q

    My CA says that I have to pay tax on interest accrued on my FD of Rs 20 lakh. I have submitted form 15H in all banks. Is it necessary to pay tax in this case?

    A

    In case of interest on fixed deposits which is taxable under the head ?Income from other Sources? a taxpayer has two choices. Either you can...

  • Q

    I want to save my money for retirment Please suggest a good insurance policy

    A

    For retirement it is advisable to use multiple investment instruments and not just life insurance policies. If you have 15 years or so for r...

  • Q

    IS IT a Good time to invest in GOLD ?

    A

    Currently the outlook for gold is bearish/negative. However if you are planning for a long-term investment in gold it is ideal to invest the...

  • Q

    I have retired from my job in November. I have got Rs 48 lakh from my employers, by way of epf, gratuity and other benefits. Should i invest in senior citizen scheme of LIC? How about pension plans from LIC?

    A

    1. You can invest Post office Senior Citizen Scheme. 2. You also should invest lumpsome in MIP in post office and get monthly interest. 3. K...

  • Q

    I want to save Rs 1 crore for my retirement when i turn 60. Now I am 42 years old and have fixed deposits worth Rs 18 lakh.What should I do to reach Rs 1 cr mark?

    A

    start investing a minimum 5000 per month in mutual fund and increase 10% to 20% every year....

  • Q

    Is it a good idea to invest in asset allocation funds? if yes, please suggest some good fund to invest money. I am 35 years old and can invest Rs 10000 per month.

    A

    Reliance Top 200 Equity is good for better return in diversified Sector....

  • Q

    I want to save on my utility bills and fuel expenses.Please suggest a good credit card for me.

    A

    Yes, you will be able to save on Utility bills and fuel expenses through the cash back schemes offered by some of the credit card companies....

  • Q

    Please suggest a good money back policy for me. I am 27 years old and want to accumulate Rs 10lakh over 10 years.

    A

    If you are a fan of traditional money back policies, go in for the LIC New Money Back Policy of 20 or 25 years. I would suggest you go in fo...

  • Q

    I want to buy a life insurance for my brother Please suggest a good policy. He is 19 years old. he should get Rs 5 lakh when he turns 25 years.

    A

    Best to go in for a ULIP in case he is looking to grow the money also. Go in for a ULIP like HDFC Click 2 Invest which is very low on charge...

  • Q

    In 2013, I bought an Endowment policy from LIC. Premium for that is around 35K per year. Now i understand, this was a big mistake and i want to go for a term insurance policy. I have already paid two premiums in 2013 and 2014 and I want to make this policy paid-up. Can i pay one more premium this year and make that endowment policy paid-up ? Or is there any better alternative ? Please suggest.

    A

    Yes, you can convert to a paid-up policy after 3 years premiums have been paid. I would recommend that you surrender the plan and take back ...

  • Q

    Is zero depreciation cover a good option under auto insurance? I have plans to buy honda city in January

    A

    Zero depreciation is a good option to along with the standard car insurance plan. By paying a slightly increased premium you can ensure that...

  • Q

    I am 20 years old,I am getting 17+ % or returns from share in my portfolio consistently for the last 6 months.should i think about a career in stockbroking?

    A

    Its nice to note that your portfolio has been gaining such high returns, however it might be too early to take a call and make stockbroking ...

  • Q

    Can investing in shares help me to save for my retirement? If yes, please suggest some shares.

    A

    You must not enter in share market at this stage, unless you are expert in this field. You should invest in equity through Equity Mutual fun...

  • Q

    Can postal savings and PPF together make a good retirement planning tool? I dont want to take share market risk?

    A

    No. You must give atleast 20-30% exposure to equity mutual fund. Saving and PPF will not beat the inflation....

  • Q

    How much tax rebate I get if I pay a premium of Rs 22000 for my parents' health insurance and Rs 12000 for accident insurance.

    A

    Under Section 80 D, you can claim deduction for insurance premium paid for any health insurance policy purchased by you for you and your fam...

  • Q

    I took a personal loan of Rs 2 lakh and repaid all the money. However the bank has recorded me as a defaulter in CIBIL. What should I do?

    A

    Please speak with the lender immediately to understand the issue. If their response is justified, you should pay the due and request them to...

Explore Moneycontrol

Copyright © e-Eighteen.com Ltd. All rights reserved. Reproduction of news articles, photos, videos or any other content in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission of moneycontrol.com is prohibited.