Tiffany & Co said on Tuesday LVMH's countersuit to drop its $16 billion acquisition of the US jeweler was an attempt to avoid paying the full purchase price.
Paris-based LVMH countersued Tiffany on Monday, arguing that its agreement with the company had no carve-out for pandemics under the definition of a so-called material adverse effect. As a result, Tiffany assumed the risk of a virus outbreak, LVMH said.
Disputing LVMH's claim that the "pandemic had devastated Tiffany's business", the US jeweler said it only experienced a single quarter of losses before returning to profitability.
"LVMH cannot show that the steps Tiffany took to protect the health and welfare of its employees and customers during the pandemic violated the Merger Agreement," Tiffany said.
The company said LVMH had still not provided it or the court with a copy of the letter from the French government that prohibited the acquisition prior to its scheduled date.