How safe are post office schemes compared with bank deposits?

Representative image

Why safety matters to small investors

Safety is usually the top priority when saving money, especially for small investors who have little leeway for putting their capital at risk. Bank fixed deposits and post office schemes both remain popular choices as they offer a guaranteed return and government guarantee. But exactly how do they match up with regard to safety, accessibility, and overall reliability?

Post office schemes: the government's guarantee

Government-supported post office schemes like the Public Provident Fund (PPF), National Savings Certificates (NSC), and income schemes on a monthly basis are guaranteed by the government. In other words, they are nearly risk-free in terms of default. Your principal amount is secure, and most of the time your returns also are fixed or locked to government-controlled rates. Post office plans are one hundred percent assurance for conservative investors who desire an easy investment option.

Bank deposits: security with flexibility

Bank FDs are another safe bet. Indian public sector banks are safe in general, and up to ₹5 lakh deposits are insured by the Deposit Insurance and Credit Guarantee Corporation (DICGC). Therefore, even when the bank is under trouble, your initial amount is secure until the insured amount. Bank FDs also turn out to be flexible in the tenor and premature withdrawal facility compared to most post office schemes.

Returns and convenience comparison

While both routes are safe, post office schemes at times offer slightly better interest rates, especially for long-term routes such as PPF. Banks may offer hot short-term rates, especially in the case of a rate hike. The second point to consider would be accessibility: post office schemes entail having to go to a post office for most transactions, whereas bank FDs can typically be done online.

Making the decision

The choice between post office schemes and bank deposits depends on your needs. If highest security, long-term investment, and slightly higher returns are your concern, post office schemes are the best choice. If convenience of withdrawal, access, and protection under insurance are your concerns, bank deposits could be your best bet. Both are utilized by investors in conjunction to diversify risk and take individual benefits.

FAQs

Q: Are post office schemes risk-free?

Yes, they are government-guaranteed and therefore very safe for principal investment.

Q: What is the cover limit for bank deposits?

Bank deposits for up to ₹5 lakh per bank per depositor are insured by DICGC.

Q: Which one is best for short-term savings?

Bank FDs are better to hold for short-term goals, whereas schemes at the post office are best for medium and long-term planning.