Payment disruption fears linger as deadline nears for merchants to delete customer card data

However, the Merchant Payments Alliance of India (MPAI), whose members include digital platforms such as Netflix, Disney+ Hotstar, Spotify, Zoom, Microsoft, and Policybazaar, says the ecosystem is not ready to implement CoFT for all use-cases.

In response to queries by Moneycontrol, Mastercard said that there are still some areas where the company is working with the stakeholders and hoping for quick resolution.

“Mastercard is continuously working with our partner banks, merchants, payment aggregators, and other stakeholders towards a seamless rollout of card-on-file tokenization services. Since the extension in December 2021, the overall industry has made significant progress and around 150 million tokens have been created across networks, including Mastercard," the company said.

Moneycontrol also reached out to Visa and RuPay who did not respond to queries.

Still testing

The alliance has reached out to the RBI and highlighted its concern that deleting card data from all platforms in the absence of complete readiness of an alternative may cause disruptions for customers and loss of revenue for merchants.

Apple has already told customers that it will not accept credit and debit card payments in India and it has asked them to use net banking, United Payments Interface or their Apple ID balance to pay for subscriptions.

“At this point in time, it will be very hard to usher in a seamless transition to the new regime,” said MPAI secretary Vivan Sharan. “While networks are ready with the required infrastructure to create tokens, work is still ongoing to process payments successfully using tokens.”

Other processes that are at development or testing stage include processing of large transaction volumes on tokens and ensuring transactions are processed quickly. There is no clarity on the execution of guest checkouts and how merchants can implement cashbacks and rewards in the absence of card data.

“Currently, e-commerce platforms execute around 900-1,000 transactions per minute,” said Mohit Kalawatia, a member of the MPAI Secretariat. “During testing with tokens, merchants have been able to process only two to eight transactions per minute.”

The success rate of those two to eight transactions was less than 1 percent, Kalawatia added.

“So, in a real-world scenario, at the current readiness, you will see only 0.05 percent of the 900-1,000 transactions going through,” he said.

According to a payments company executive who did not wish to be identified, the card networks are in talks with the RBI for clarification on these fronts.

“For some of the issues, there are solutions but they all include temporary storage of card data,” the executive said. “The card networks are yet to get a response from the RBI on these proposed solutions. What the ecosystem is worried about is that if the card networks come up with an RBI-approved solution very close to the deadline, then it will be very difficult to implement them in time.”

Deadline extension?

Opinions are divided on whether the RBI will consider requests to extend the deadline to purge data again.

“Looking at the readiness, the RBI may extend the deadline again,” said former finance secretary Subhash Chandra Garg. “But that is just handling the issue symptomatically. In my judgement, the RBI should rollback these guidelines and simultaneously allow tokenisation to be implemented with more checks and clarity. But eliminating card details will not be in public interest.”

However, the executive said the RBI is unlikely to budge again.

“No discussions of an extension may be entertained by the RBI this time. The regulator will say that we are still in exactly the same position as six months ago,” the executive said.

This will be the second major disruption in payments, coming after the central bank’s recurring payment norms that led to failed subscriptions and revenue loss for small businesses.

But recurring payments made up only 3 percent of all payments in India. These norms, on the other hand, will have a wider impact, affecting all card payments.

According to Rameesh Kailasam, CEO of IndiaTech.org, which represents tech startups, the larger issue is that customers too are not completely aware of how CoFT will work.

“There is nothing which has been done for customers’ capacity building and handholding. Our request is that the RBI should do a status check to see if the market is ready. Banks and card networks need to be ready for the experience to be frictionless and smooth for the customer,” he said.

Once card networks and banks are ready with tokenisation, they will have to share the application programming interface (API) with merchants for them to align their own systems.

MPAI’s Sharan said, “When we ask for an extension, we don’t mean to say we don’t want to purge data. We are happy to do that and have lighter servers. For us, it is just a question of implementing this when everything is in place without any setbacks for customers or merchants.”