Delhi cracks down on vehicle pollution under GRAP-IV but are PUC tests effective enough?

Are current emission tests effective enough?

Experts say that the current on-road vehicle emission testing system has serious limitations. At present, PUC tests are based mainly on idle testing, where emissions of carbon monoxide (CO) and hydrocarbons (HC) are measured when the engine is running at low speed. For diesel vehicles, a smoke density test is conducted, while petrol vehicles also undergo a lambda test.

Experts point out that this method does not reflect real-world driving conditions, where vehicles emit higher levels of pollutants during acceleration and high-speed driving.

Researchers from Delhi Technological University (DTU) have earlier proposed an improved system similar to the Air Quality Index (AQI), known as an Exhaust Emission Index (EEI). This system also considers the mileage and maintenance status of vehicles while assessing emissions.

Call for testing beyond idle emissions

Dr Rajeev Kumar Mishra, associate professor at DTU’s department of environmental science and engineering, said emission testing and re-certification for in-use vehicles must go beyond idle conditions. “Currently, PUC certificates are issued based only on CO and hydrocarbon emissions when the engine is idle. This does not capture emissions like nitrogen dioxide (NO₂), fine particulate matter (PM2.5) and volatile organic compounds (VOCs), which are released in higher amounts during fast idling or acceleration,” he was quoted by TOI as saying.

Mishra added that emissions at higher engine speeds, such as 2,500 rpm, are sometimes recorded but are not considered while issuing certificates. He stressed that decisions on whether a vehicle should be allowed to operate or phased out should depend on accumulated mileage, maintenance history and overall emission performance, not just the age of the vehicle.

He also noted that there are no clear emission testing standards for BS-VI vehicles, and testing norms vary across different Bharat Stage categories.

Vehicles major contributor to Delhi’s pollution

According to studies by the Centre for Science and Environment (CSE), vehicle emissions are among the largest contributors to air pollution in Delhi and have a direct impact on public health. While PUC checks can help identify highly polluting vehicles, they do not fully address harmful pollutants such as PM2.5 and toxic gases.

“Vehicles are the second-largest source of particulate emissions in Delhi. Their emissions are especially dangerous because they occur at breathing height,” TOI quoted Shambhavi Shukla, programme manager for air pollution at CSE, as saying.

She suggested adopting advanced vehicle emission surveillance systems, including remote sensing technologies, to detect polluting vehicles more effectively.

What are the issues at PUC centres?

Experts also highlighted long-standing problems at PUC centres. An audit conducted by CSE and the Environment Pollution (Prevention and Control) Authority (EPCA) in 2017 found serious irregularities. In some cases, certificates were issued without inserting probes into vehicle exhausts. Some centres allegedly had only printers, with no proper testing equipment, and results varied widely between centres.

Shukla said staff at PUC centres are required to have proper technical training, but this is often not enforced. She stressed that unless these issues are fixed, emission testing will continue to fall short of its goal.