Battle for the world's best comfort food: It's Korean fried chicken Vs Japanese karaage

Also read: Inside Mumbai’s newest Japanese restaurant Akina

This year, judges were appointed to replace a public vote after allegations of fowl play by some of the competing pubs, restaurants and chicken shops. The judges met for several tasting sessions around the country - each putting away around a kilogram of chicken a day.

Lead judge Koichiro Yagi, who also serves as managing director of the Japan Karaage Association, told AFP he was looking for fried chicken that "tells a story". "There's an initial flavour, then a secondary flavour, then an aftertaste," he said, wearing a traditional Japanese coat bearing the slogan "karaage changes the world".

"The initial flavour draws you in with the aroma and the taste, but the real pleasure of karaage is the journey it takes you on."

Also read: Your sushi experience is in danger due to climate change; but this time it’s not the fish

The town of Nakatsu, on the southern island of Kyushu, has a reputation for producing Japan's best karaage (Image: AFP)

The town of Nakatsu, on the southern island of Kyushu, has a reputation for producing Japan's best karaage, and its shops have won several prizes at the Karaage Grand Prix. But competition from the rest of the country is fierce, and some cooks go to great lengths to give themselves an edge. "There are lots of chicken shops in Nakatsu and we went there and tried each and every one," said Takehiro Matsumoto, whose Tokyo-based brand has won Karaage Grand Prix awards for the past three years running.

Also read: Inja, Delhi’s bold new Indo-Japanese concept fine-dining, is a flavour tease

"It wasn't just Nakatsu - if there was a place that people said was good, we went there and studied them all to find the best."

'Never get sick of it' 
The contest, now in its 14th year, hands out prizes in categories such as soy sauce or salt-based flavours - and splits the awards between east and west Japan. An overall winner is crowned in each category, with several lesser "gold" awards also handed out.

"The initial flavour draws you in with the aroma and the taste, but the real pleasure of karaage is the journey it takes you on," says an enthusiast (Image: AFP)

Until this year, winners were determined by public vote, and tales abounded of shops creating email addresses en masse to rig the system. Kazuhiko Nakano, managing director of a pub chain that has won gold awards in different categories, said he was glad that this year's competition was decided by the judges' discerning palates.

"In the past, people would vote without even tasting it," said Nakano, adding that his firm saw an 80 percent rise in karaage sales after winning their first award in 2020. "When you have judges, there is a standard of what is tasty."

The judges were largely drawn from food industries associated with karaage, and sampled around 25 entries a day. Each entrant was given five minutes to present their product, while judges chewed on pineapple between bites of chicken to aid digestion.

"I've been eating karaage almost every day for more than 10 years - I've eaten at 3,300 different karaage places," said judge Iku Arino, who styles herself as a karaage influencer. "I never get sick of it."

After much deliberation, the judges reconvened to announce the winners at a ceremony in Tokyo this week.

Tatsuya Oyama, whose Tokyo shop "Karaage-ya Oshu Iwai" scooped the East Japan prize for best soy sauce flavour, said his award was "more meaningful" than his previous two, because it had been chosen by experts. Lead judge Yagi said the new system had been successful but stomach-busting, and vowed to reduce the load on the panel's plates at next year's edition.

But while the champions can concentrate on turning their award-winning status into profit, Yagi said there was no such thing as the perfect karaage. "It changes depending on the situation in which you're eating it," he said.

"It also depends on who you're eating it with and how you're eating it. Asking 'what is the perfect karaage?' is a difficult question."