EU wants more medical device controls after PIP scare

By Charlie Dunmore

BRUSSELS (Reuters) - European Union governments should strengthen safety controls on high-risk medical devices by using spot checks on products and manufacturing facilities after the scare over faulty silicone breast implants, the EU's health chief said on Thursday.

Europe's weak regulations on medical devices have been partly blamed for allowing French company Poly Implant Prothese (PIP) to manufacture substandard silicone breast implants for up to a decade, and be used by hundreds of thousands of unwitting women around the world.

"I am deeply concerned about the potential health impact for the many women, in Europe and in other parts of the world, who received faulty silicone breast implants manufactured by the French company PIP," EU health and consumer affairs chief John Dalli told a news briefing in Brussels.

"The consequences for their health are still uncertain."

Dalli said he had written to the bloc's 27 health ministers and urged them to make full use existing EU rules. He called for an urgent review of the 70 to 80 regulatory agencies responsible for approving high-risk medical devices in Europe, most of which are private companies.

Within months, EU governments should ensure the agencies, known as notified bodies, are only authorised to assess and approve devices and technologies for which they have a proven expertise and competence, Dalli said.

"I have asked my colleagues in the member states for their personal commitment to implementing these actions as a matter of priority," he said.

"I know that we all subscribe to the need to put patients first and to restore trust in our regulatory system."

The Commission said the measures would boost surveillance of a European market for medical devices and diagnostics - worth an estimated 78 billion euros in sales in 2007 - while it drafted a full overhaul of existing EU legislation in the coming months.

The EU executive has also ordered its scientific experts to carry out a further study into the potential health impacts of the PIP implants, after an initial report found insufficient evidence women using the implants were at a greater risk than others.

(Reporting by Charlie Dunmore; editing by Rex Merrifield)