Mar 14, 2013, 02.06 PM | Source: Moneycontrol.com

Budget 2013: Will it help in reducing tax disputes and litigations?

Despite Government’s attempts to simplify the tax regime, India still witnesses a complex multi-tier and multi-rate system of transaction taxes levied both by the Federal and State Government.

Puneet Bansal & Saurabh Agarwal
BMR & Associates

Despite Government’s attempts to simplify the tax regime, India still witnesses a complex multi-tier and multi-rate system of transaction taxes levied both by the Federal and State Government. 

The already complex structure of transaction taxes becomes more difficult for taxpayers due to frequent changes in legislations both at the Federal and State level.  While many changes are introduced by the Government in Federal taxes in past with a noble intent and are welcomed by the industry at large, disputes often arise at the stage of their implementation. 

With the high pace of legislative changes, the Government and taxpayers have, in recent times, seen litigating on a large number of issues due to difference in interpretation.  As a result, significant amount of time, money and efforts get deployed both by taxpayers as well as the Government in long-drawn litigations coupled with retrospective / prospective tax amendments. Above all, it creates uncertainty both for the taxpayers and the Government with regard to tax liability of a transaction and adds to the growing perception that India is a difficult place to do business.

Another reason for the increase in number of tax disputes and litigation is an under-staffed administration, and in some cases, inexperienced in tackling the rapidly changing indirect tax laws and issues arising there under.  This coupled with the fact that the same adjudication authorities simultaneously carry the additional burden of tax collection (to meet the revenue targets set by the Government).

Regularly, we read figures of thousands of crores of Rupees stuck in tax litigations but Government must ponder as to how much of such litigations will actually be decided in its favor. This is evident from a low success rate of Government in tax litigations eventually.

Also, lots of demand notices are issued by the department based on the objections of the audit authorities / CAG without examining the legality of the issue in entirety.

Under this economic scenario, the taxpayers look forward to a few path breaking amendments in Indirect Tax laws that make tax laws certain and reduce the disputes & litigations.

As a first step, the Government can consider widening the scope of Advance Ruling which is presently restricted only to non-residents / Public Sector Companies and that too for proposed transactions.  The scope may be widened to provide an opportunity to the domestic private industry & existing transactions as well to have certainty of taxes by seeking an Advance Ruling on vexed issues.

Also, strict timelines may be introduced for adjudication of notices / appeals by the departmental officers / Courts to reduce the pendency of litigations and to expedite the dispute resolution.

Further, the Government may consider separating the adjudication officers from the jurisdictional field formations. This step may ensure that the show cause notices are adjudicated judiciously thereby lowering the number of cases that enter the main stream litigation.

While the above measures may lead to dispute resolution going forward, the need of this hour is to settle the huge pendency of indirect tax litigations pending at various tax forums. The government may introduce an Alternate Dispute Resolution Panel for decision on pending litigations. 

The above measures would go a long way in ensuring that the much sought after reform of the Government in the form of introduction of Goods and Services Tax (GST) could be implemented in true spirits with least burden on the revenue authorities and the tax payers with respect to pending unsettled litigations of the old regime. Also, such an approach will go a long way in reducing the litigations in the upcoming GST regime.

The increasing number of disputes and litigations in the recent past added to the existing pain for the industry already suffering from the hard hit recession.  The industry expects reforms to be brought by the Government in the current budget which would bring down the disputes and litigations in future. However, whether this budget would fulfill such expectations, is a thing to watch out for?

ADS BY GOOGLE

Ask the Experts

Get your Personal Finance queries answered

  • Q

    If I put Rs 2 lakh in PPF, how much tax rebate I will get?

    A

    As per the existing guidelines and rules a person cannot deposit more than 1.5 lacs in one PPF account. However you can deposit money in the...

  • Q

    Interest rates are going to go down. And all my fixed deposits will be maturing next year. I will have to renew my fixed deposits next year at lower rate of interest. What is the way out?

    A

    Interest rates keep fluctuating due to various micro- and macro- economic factors. There is never an ideal rate of interest. In a high inter...

  • Q

    I want to buy online term life insuance plan. Which is the best one? Should I go for single premium or regular premium policy?

    A

    Single premium term insurance policies don?t make much sense. Why pay such a large amount at one go when you have the option of paying in sm...

  • Q

    I want to invest some money with at least ten years view. I dont want share market risk. Can I invest in NSC? Is there any other investment option?

    A

    NSC or National Savings Certificate is a safe investment scheme offered by the Central Government. It is an ideal option for investors with ...

  • Q

    My CA says that I have to pay tax on interest accrued on my FD of Rs 20 lakh. I have submitted form 15H in all banks. Is it necessary to pay tax in this case?

    A

    In case of interest on fixed deposits which is taxable under the head ?Income from other Sources? a taxpayer has two choices. Either you can...

  • Q

    I want to save my money for retirment Please suggest a good insurance policy

    A

    For retirement it is advisable to use multiple investment instruments and not just life insurance policies. If you have 15 years or so for r...

  • Q

    IS IT a Good time to invest in GOLD ?

    A

    Currently the outlook for gold is bearish/negative. However if you are planning for a long-term investment in gold it is ideal to invest the...

  • Q

    I have retired from my job in November. I have got Rs 48 lakh from my employers, by way of epf, gratuity and other benefits. Should i invest in senior citizen scheme of LIC? How about pension plans from LIC?

    A

    1. You can invest Post office Senior Citizen Scheme. 2. You also should invest lumpsome in MIP in post office and get monthly interest. 3. K...

  • Q

    I want to save Rs 1 crore for my retirement when i turn 60. Now I am 42 years old and have fixed deposits worth Rs 18 lakh.What should I do to reach Rs 1 cr mark?

    A

    start investing a minimum 5000 per month in mutual fund and increase 10% to 20% every year....

  • Q

    Is it a good idea to invest in asset allocation funds? if yes, please suggest some good fund to invest money. I am 35 years old and can invest Rs 10000 per month.

    A

    Reliance Top 200 Equity is good for better return in diversified Sector....

  • Q

    I want to save on my utility bills and fuel expenses.Please suggest a good credit card for me.

    A

    Yes, you will be able to save on Utility bills and fuel expenses through the cash back schemes offered by some of the credit card companies....

  • Q

    Please suggest a good money back policy for me. I am 27 years old and want to accumulate Rs 10lakh over 10 years.

    A

    If you are a fan of traditional money back policies, go in for the LIC New Money Back Policy of 20 or 25 years. I would suggest you go in fo...

  • Q

    I want to buy a life insurance for my brother Please suggest a good policy. He is 19 years old. he should get Rs 5 lakh when he turns 25 years.

    A

    Best to go in for a ULIP in case he is looking to grow the money also. Go in for a ULIP like HDFC Click 2 Invest which is very low on charge...

  • Q

    In 2013, I bought an Endowment policy from LIC. Premium for that is around 35K per year. Now i understand, this was a big mistake and i want to go for a term insurance policy. I have already paid two premiums in 2013 and 2014 and I want to make this policy paid-up. Can i pay one more premium this year and make that endowment policy paid-up ? Or is there any better alternative ? Please suggest.

    A

    Yes, you can convert to a paid-up policy after 3 years premiums have been paid. I would recommend that you surrender the plan and take back ...

  • Q

    Is zero depreciation cover a good option under auto insurance? I have plans to buy honda city in January

    A

    Zero depreciation is a good option to along with the standard car insurance plan. By paying a slightly increased premium you can ensure that...

  • Q

    I am 20 years old,I am getting 17+ % or returns from share in my portfolio consistently for the last 6 months.should i think about a career in stockbroking?

    A

    Its nice to note that your portfolio has been gaining such high returns, however it might be too early to take a call and make stockbroking ...

  • Q

    Can investing in shares help me to save for my retirement? If yes, please suggest some shares.

    A

    You must not enter in share market at this stage, unless you are expert in this field. You should invest in equity through Equity Mutual fun...

  • Q

    Can postal savings and PPF together make a good retirement planning tool? I dont want to take share market risk?

    A

    No. You must give atleast 20-30% exposure to equity mutual fund. Saving and PPF will not beat the inflation....

  • Q

    How much tax rebate I get if I pay a premium of Rs 22000 for my parents' health insurance and Rs 12000 for accident insurance.

    A

    Under Section 80 D, you can claim deduction for insurance premium paid for any health insurance policy purchased by you for you and your fam...

  • Q

    I took a personal loan of Rs 2 lakh and repaid all the money. However the bank has recorded me as a defaulter in CIBIL. What should I do?

    A

    Please speak with the lender immediately to understand the issue. If their response is justified, you should pay the due and request them to...

Explore Moneycontrol

Copyright © e-Eighteen.com Ltd. All rights reserved. Reproduction of news articles, photos, videos or any other content in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission of moneycontrol.com is prohibited.