Beware of MF dividend declarations!

"XYZ Scheme is declaring 100% dividend and my distributor is telling me to invest in this scheme" . "This is important information which I have received from my relationship manager that ABC Scheme is declaring a dividend of 50%". I come across statements like this every now and then where dividends declared by mutual funds are used as a bait to get investors to invest. The scenario is presented in a manner that if you invest Rs. 1 lakh today , you will receive a Rs. 30000 as dividend or some other amount based on the NAV of the fund. Nothing could be further from the truth.

Dividends are not any form of additional gains that you can expect. In fact, dividend in Mutual Funds is a function of Capital Appreciation. Let's say you invest on 20th September Rs. 5 lakh  at an NAV of Rs. 50. This means you end up getting 10000 units (have excluded Entry load for simplicity).

Investment	Rs. 500000
NAV	Rs. 50
Number of Units	10000
Dividend Declared	100%  (i.e Rs. 10)
Dividend Received	Rs.10 * 10000 = Rs. 100000

 

 

 

Happy aren't you to receive Rs. 1 Lakh as dividend. I wish it was this simple and easy to make money in just a few days . There would be far more billionaires and millionaires than we have now.

Now for the catch, after the dividend is declared the NAV of the fund falls down from Rs. 50.00 to Rs.40.00

Value of your holding = 10000*40= Rs. 400000. This along with the dividend already received of Rs. 1 lakh will translate into your original investment of Rs. 5 lakh. So you see things are not as rosy as they are projected to be.

POST DIVIDEND
NAV	Rs. 40.00
Number of Units	10000
Investment	Rs. 400000
Dividend Received	Rs.10 * 10000 = Rs. 100000
Total Amount in hand	Rs. 5000000 same as earlier

 

 

 

 

So how should one react to these advertisements that a 100% dividend is being declared or should anyone invest just on the basis of this information. The answer is an outright no. However, People have utilized a strategy called Dividend Stripping on the basis of this information. This was more rampant when Mutual Funds used to declare dividends a month or so before the record date.

The way it works is as follows. Suppose you have a short term gain of around Rs. 100000 . Instead of paying a short term capital gains tax of Rs. 10000 (considering 10 % short term capital gains), you make an investment of Rs. 100000 in a fund to declare a dividend of say around 25% (NAV= Rs. 25 ) .

Number of Units you have : 4000
Dividend per unit = Rs. 2.50 (25%)
Total Dividend Received : Rs. 10000
Value of your investment now : 4000 units * NAV (RS. 25-10%) Rs. 22.50 = Rs. 90000
Redeem your investment now for Rs. 90000 and you have a Rs. 10000 Short Term Capital Loss.

POST DIVIDEND
NAV	Rs. 22.50
Number of Units	4000
Investment	Rs. 90000
Dividend Received	Rs.2.50 * 4000 = Rs. 10000
Total Amount in hand	Rs. 100000 same as earlier

 

 

 

 

Here you have received tax free dividend and you have been able to offset this against your short term capital gains.

Now your short term gain is around 90000 instead of earlier Rs. 100000. This results in a saving of around Rs. 1000 or 10% for you.

Short term Capital Gain	Rs. 1,00,000
Loss from sale of investment post dividend	Rs. 10,000
Net Short term Capital Gain	Rs. 90000
Saving in Short term Capital Gains tax	10% of 10,000 = Rs. 1,000

 

 

 

 

IT Department through its annual budget have tried to fix this loophole by increasing the holding period of the investment post the record date based on whether it was bought 3 months before the record date or within 3 months of the record date.

SEBI on the other hand issued guidelines that required the AMC to issue a notice communicating the decision to distribute dividends within 1 calendar day of decision by the trustees. At the same time the record date should be 5 calendar days from the issue of this notice. Though these are steps in the right direction and dividend stripping has been slowed to a certain extent, AMCs in the race to gather more assets are still using this as a ploy.

Don't fall for this or any such trick as your purpose of investing in equity oriented funds should be capital appreciation and not because a dividend is being declared. Dividend Payout, Dividend Reinvestment and Growth are options to choose based on your situation and need. Mutual Funds can only pay out dividends if they have made gains on the portfolio.  Dividends are like fruits on a tree...If you do not give enough time for the tree to grow...where will the fruits come from...Don't know about this but your dividend will certainly come out from your principal.

- Amar Pandit

The author is a practising Certified Financial Planner. He can be reached at amar.pandit@moneycontrol.com

For more Columns by Experts click here