Landmark Ruling on Applicability of Service Tax

1520 Investors following BSNL. Share this News with them.

0

Like this story, share it with millions of investors on M3

Landmark Ruling on Applicability of Service Tax

By: Bipin Sapra, Ernst & Young

Post your opinion here

 

0

Tweet

Share on Tumblr

BSE | NSE 01/01/70 Are Mutual Funds betting on ?

By: Bipin Sapra, Tax Partner, Ernst & Young

The issue of facing tax demands both from service tax and sales tax authorities on transactions involving goods and services has long troubled the services sector. Similarly, in the telecom industry where the issue of whether supply of SIM cards during the provision of telecom service attracts sales tax or service tax, has for long been a bone of contention and protracted litigation. Now the Supreme Court ('SC') in its recent judgment in the case of Idea Mobile Communication. v CCE, Cochin  (Idea Mobile) has put this issue to rest. The SC has conclusively held that telecom operators will be required to pay service tax on the gross amount received from subscribers towards activation charges which includes the value of SIM card supplied to the subscriber.

To appreciate the above decision of the SC it is relevant to look at the history of the controversy relating to levy of sales tax or service tax on the sale of SIM cards. In 2002 Kerala High Court in the case of Escotel Mobile Communications. (which later merged with Idea Mobile Communication) held that sale of SIM cards was liable to sales tax as well as service tax. This judgment was overruled by SC in the case of Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited (BSNL)  and the Court remanded the matter back to the tax authorities to decide the issue on facts so that multiple taxes do not apply on the same value.

In the second round of litigation, when the matter reached the SC again after crossing the tribunal and High Court stages, the SC taking note of the BSNL judgment conclusively held that SIM cards are never sold or transacted as goods independent from the telecommunication services provided. The SC further held that SIM card being an essential part of service has no intrinsic value or purpose other than use in mobile phones. The dominant use of SIM card is towards activation and provision of telecommunication services and not as separate sale of goods. While arriving at the above findings the SC also went by the submission that the sales tax authorities have dropped proceedings to levy sales tax on supply of SIM cards. Accordingly, the SC held that there can be only service tax which can be charged on the SIM card; and any sales tax wrongly paid to the state sales tax authorities does not absolve the tax payer of its liability to pay service tax on the same amount.

Impact of SC's order on the Service Industry

The SC's order is a step in right direction in as much it clearly lays down that in cases where the dominant intention is to provide services any incidental supply of goods does not change the dominant nature of the transaction as a service transaction. It also takes forward the ideology of "one tax" promulgated in the BSNL judgment that SIM cards are liable only for payment of service tax.

It is now expected that for telecom as well as other service sectors, all similar pending issues at various adjudication forums will now get expeditiously settled and the taxpayer will not face issues of multiple taxation both from the sales tax and service tax authorities.

(Views expressed are personal)