Mar 28, 2012, 03.53 PM | Source: CNBC-TV18

GAAR: FIIs will flee to Singapore, says HP Ranina

HP Ranina, corporate tax lawyer spoke to CNBC-TV18 about the contours of applicability of GAAR.

HP Ranina, corporate tax lawyer spoke to CNBC-TV18 about the contours of applicability of GAAR. He says that though P-notes will not be targeted, FIIs are likely to move away to Singapore. India does not have a DTAA with Singapore yet. “Lot of investments could come into the tax net if FIIs still operate from Mauritius,” he explains.

Below is the edited transcript of the interview. Also watch the accompanying video.

Q: We hear that the P-notes themselves are not getting targeted, but more importantly there will be several tests applied, one of the four test must be satisfied for the GAAR to apply, your reactions?

A: I am glad that they are clarifying this matter and that P-notes or participatory notes are not going to be targeted. I think it will certainly help to stabilize the market in the short run.

Q: The four tests have been mentioned and one of these four must be satisfied for GAAR to get applicable. Does it give you a sense that it will become applicable to a large number of cases because even one out of the four, if it is satisfied, the tax department can go ahead with anti-avoidance rules?

A: Yes, you are absolutely right. This will certainly create a lot of problems, for example in the case of companies set up in Mauritius, even if they just have a tax residency certificate that will not be accepted, they will have to prove that that company had some commercial substance, they are carrying on some activity, genuine bonafide activity and therefore, once the test is not satisfied, they will invoke the GAAR. Of course, that will happen from 1st April 2012, it will not happen in this week, but from next year, and that also it will happen only after the Finance Bill is passed and approved by the President of India, which would be happening in the third week of May. So from that day onwards, they will immediately start saying that you are not satisfying the condition of commercial substance in respect of your property, in respect of the company which you have, and therefore we will not give you the benefit of tax exemption of the treaty.

Q: The onus was so far on the FII to prove that the entity created was not primarily for tax saving purposes. The language that our team here is using is the I-T Department will also have to prove commercial purpose test, bona fide purpose test and misuse and abuse test. Do you think this is sort of passing on the onus now to the I-T Department to prove that the entity is not only for tax saving purposes?

A: Yes that will, but that doesn’t give any benefit because the income tax officer will simply say ‘I am not convinced that you are having any commercial substance in Mauritius, say you don’t have so many employees, you are not doing any other work, you are just operating from a lawyer’s office and therefore I am convinced that there is no commercial substance and therefore I am invoking GAAR.’

Q: So your sense is that a lot of investments out of Mauritius will not be able to hide under the DTAA and will become taxable you think?

A: Yes, it would mean that. In fact, it doesn’t help the FIIs at all. It only empowers the Income Tax Department to take their stand, even if they satisfy on one issue, they will invoke GAAR and that is why what I said yesterday, most companies will now shift to Singapore because that is where there is some stringency in the laws, they issue a tax residency certificate only if you show that you are some employee, you are doing some other activity, maybe trading activity or any other activity then they issue the TRC. So a lot of FIIs are now planning to shift there, that’s my sense.

Q: How much will FII investments be disturbed?

A: A lot of investments could come under a tax net if they still continue to operate from Mauritius because that is where the difficulties will arise. Unless they now change their position, they do some other activity in Mauritius as well and not just operate from a lawyer’s office. So maybe they can also change, then those companies which want to retain the Mauritian tax benefit will now start some other substantial activity because as I said, GAAR will come into effect only from sometime in May once the finance bill is passed. Therefore they have couple of months to set their things in order. It all depends on how they reorganize themselves and to what extent they are still interested in taking advantage of the Indo-Mauritian tax treaty.

Q: There is also news coming in that the government will try and classify the P-note as a separate asset class altogether. Do you think direct investments that the FIIs have through a structure that’s been created only for tax saving purposes could be hit, so does the focus now shift to direct FIIs and entities created for tax saving purposes and alleviates the P-note pressure?

A: Yes, it will now shift entirely to FII direct investments and P-notes obviously will be out of the tax, that will be for a time being, but we still have to wait and watch, things are pretty fluid at this point of time. We never know when the government may take a different view. So currently of course that clarification is helpful as far as P-notes are concerned.


Ask the Experts

Get your Personal Finance queries answered

  • Q

    i have been investing in the follwoing MF for the past one year should i contiune or switch to other funds. 1 Axis equity fund direct(g) 2 Axis gold fung direct (g) 3 Birla Sun Life Dynamic Bond Fund - Retail Plan dirct (g) 4HDFC Mid-Cap Opportunities Fund (G) 5 ICICI Prudential Dynamic Plan - Direct Plan (G) 6 ICICI Prudential Top 200 Fund (G) advice if i have to switch, all are for long term


    All the schemes look fine and you may continue. The amount that you invest in respective schemes is not known, so just make sure you have al...

  • Q

    i want to investment in 60 lacs invest in mutual fund and i accept 16 percentage return per year my goal after 10 years 2.80crs what is possible please true guide


    Equities over a long term are expected to give a return of 14-17%. Sensex has given a return of approx. 17% since inception i.e 1979-80 till...

  • Q

    Iwant to invest rs10l free of risk ! Shd i go for bank fd's or as the bank suggest " guaranteed income plan" ? Please guide .


    Yes bank returns are fixed....

  • Q

    My daughter 18 yrs. old is studying at IIT Madras for engineering. She is a tax payer in the 20% slab. I wish to get her a LIC policy at an early age. The agent recomends JEEVAN ANAND from LIC of India. Kindly advise the best options.


    Hello, Jeevan Anand is a with-profit plan by LIC which has an insurance component as well. It is always recommended not to mix insurance and...

  • Q

    I am 40 years old working in private company. Want to invest open ended fund Rs. 2000 per month. Kindly suggest


    The scheme that you should invest into would depend upon your time horizon. If you can stay invested for long term ( 7 yrs + ) then you shou...

  • Q

    I am planning to invest a lumspum of Rs 10000 in Mutual Fund for 2 years horizon. Please suggest me some good funds which will provide me maximum returns. I am ready to bear the risk. Would appreciate your advises. Thanks


    For a period of 2 years, I would suggest that you invest in a dynamic bond fund. However, since you have mentioned that you wish to take ris...

  • Q

    Dear sir/madam i am Dhananjay Surve from mumbai .I have got placement through my engineering college and working sience last 2 months .Ia am 22 years old ,i s investing in sip is good for me .As iam looking for time period of 3 to 5 years from now for investment ,which will be the best fund and what other investment option will be best .i am looking for 2 to 2.5 k per month investment.


    Invest the entire amount in a balanced fund. Its a good way to get an understanding about mutual fund working and investments. Invest in Tat...

Explore Moneycontrol

Copyright © Ltd. All rights reserved. Reproduction of news articles, photos, videos or any other content in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission of is prohibited.