Govt slams S&Ps Math; rubbishes downgrade risks

A visibly upset economic affairs secretary Arvind Mayaram said that the maths behind this conclusion was questionable and was nothing short of crystal ball gazing.
  • Language
  • App
  • Subscriptions
  • Specials
  • Sign-In
  • Register
GeStepAhead master your money Realasset

Home » News » CNBC-TV18 Comments

Sep 07, 2013, 06.50 PM | Source: CNBC-TV18

Govt slams S&P's Math; rubbishes downgrade risks

A visibly upset economic affairs secretary Arvind Mayaram said that the maths behind this conclusion was "questionable" and was nothing short of crystal ball gazing.

Like this story, share it with millions of investors on M3

Govt slams S&Ps Math; rubbishes downgrade risks

A visibly upset economic affairs secretary Arvind Mayaram said that the maths behind this conclusion was "questionable" and was nothing short of crystal ball gazing.

Post Your Comments

Share Cancel

Siddharth Zarabi (more)

Economic Editor, CNBC-TV18 |

The Finance Ministry is once again upset with the poor souls at Standard & Poors, for having dared to express a 33 per cent possibility of India's rating being downgraded in three years. A visibly upset economic affairs secretary Arvind Mayaram said that the maths behind this conclusion was "questionable" and was nothing short of crystal ball gazing. Arguing that there was no case for downgrading India, the official, who spoke with the media on way to the G-20 Summit,  rubbed it in further by adding that if a growth slowdown was the cause for a rating action, then the agency may just as well "downgrade the whole world".
There is a though, a much bigger message  that India is carrying to the eighth gathering of the world's top 20 nations. No less than Prime Minister Manmohan Singh himself will deliver it once the Summit gets underway on Thursday at the historical city of St. Petersburg, which among other keystones, is also the birthplace of Vladmir Putin, the host of the Summit. 

Also read: PM arrives in Russia for G20 Summit
Singh, who recently told Parliament that he was heard with respect in the G-20 council, shall deliver a simple, if plaintive message to Barack Obama: ask your Federal Reserve to keep printing more money. "I will emphasise on the need for an orderly exit from the unconventional monetary policies being pursued by the developed world for the last few years, so as to avoid damaging the growth prospects of the developing world", the PM said before leaving India. He added that though there were encouraging sings of growth in the industrialised world, "there is a slowdown in emerging economies, which are facing the adverse impact of the significant capital outflows". Clearly, the party is about to get over and some guests just don't want to leave.
This remark, coupled with those of officials later, frame the dilemma neatly. In Mayaram's words, if the excess liquidity of the Greenspan years and the post-crash recovery by 2010 "was bad for India", the anticipated "pullback shall also create problems". China, Brazil and even South Africa are expected to join hands with India and seek a more orderly and predictable pullback from the stimulus. Even the plain speaking Raghuram Rajan has decided to deliver his first review of monetary policy on September 20. By then, the US Federal Reserve would have hopefully made it clear, and in understandable English, what exactly it means by "tapering".
So, does it look like that India has plan B for another "end-of-the-world financial cataclysm"? History suggests otherwise, but the government seems to suggest that tackling the domestic end of the ongoing crisis will help the country ride out of the woods. It is in this regard that Mayaram advances a few arguments, the crux of which is that the Indian economy would grow at 5.5% this fiscal, in line with the government and central bank estimates. This on the back of a fresh spending drive, largely by the central government as well the states, several of whom are headed for assembly elections.

Nearly half of the budgeted Plan expenditure of almost Rs 5.55 lakh crore has been released to states and should be spent over the next six to nine months, neatly coinciding with the run up to the general election. This by itself, and not accounting for election expenditure on the "private" account via cash, should be big pump primer for growth by this December or thereabouts. The comparison with what happened last year, after P. Chidambaram, assumed office as Finance Minister, is even more stark. As Mayaram puts it, the first quarter GDP growth dip came on the back of a sharp 120 bps contraction in the FY13 deficit. "No other country in the world has done something as drastic. That was the reason for the growth dip in the first quarter of the current fiscal, but the second and third quarters should be better", he says.
The good monsoon is the second silver lining and Mayaram says there has been a nine per cent expansion in the farm sowing area, an indicator of a bumper harvest by Diwali. This, he predicts, would give a 100 bps push up to full year GDP growth. On top of this, the $ 30 billion worth of project clearances accorded over the past six months should also bear positive results via improved investment into the country.
Some dark clouds though persist, notably rising international crude oil prices and the fears over Syria. Russia has already warned against any US intervention and while the Summit could help create a consensus on an international response to alleged use of chemical weapons in the conflict zone, the fact is that the Indian basket of crude oil is slowly creeping back up at around $ 112.5 to the barrel. This would pose a concern for the oil subsidy bill and pressure the fiscal deficit target of 4.8 per cent of GDP for this year. The prospect of panicky investors retreating even further from emerging markets due to an escalation is also weighing heavy on the Indian policy establishment. 
Prime Minister Manmohan Singh has used previous G-20 Summits to speak about the need for the developed world to invest in the infrastructure of developing countries and thereby rebalance things a bit. His pet theme seems to be finally resonating with the global order. The World Bank is working on a Global Infrastructure Funding facility of sorts, the final contours of which will be presented at the Summit here. Singh is of the firm view that infrastructure investment flows would stimulate global growth.
Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee got more than his fair share blame due to what were termed as regressive tax policies that targeted a global giant like Vodafone. P. Chidambaram has since spent considerable time trying to untie the knots. But, globally the mood on the erosion of tax base and profit shifting to avoid paying tax is turning against such practices. For the first time, the G-20 will consider a OECD paper on the subject. India has contributed to the debate and officials are clear that while the country is not going after multinationals, they will have to pay due tax. Fair play and equity, they argue is required, as India cannot afford erosion of its rather limited tax base.

Ads by Google

Buy, Hold, Sell ? Hear it first on M3
Govt slams S&Ps Math; rubbishes downgrade risks

See all

Get started using your favorite social network


Login using moneycontrol ID


Need help logging in? Reset password.

Don´t have an account? Sign Up

Get started using your favorite social network


Simply sign up using this short form

* mandatory


Username should be atleast 4 character


Password should be 8 or more characters,
atleast 1 number, 1 symbol & 1 upper case letter


Your Password should contain
  • 8 or more characters
  • At least 1 number
  • At least 1 symbol
  • At least 1 upper case letter
Confirm Password*
Already have an account? Login