Real-time Stock quotes, portfolio, LIVE TV and more.
Apr 30, 2012, 06.38 PM IST
The telecom commission is seeking clarity on issues related to 2G spectrum auction including auction reserve price. The proposals of the telecom regulator have been severely criticised by service providers like Bharti, Vodafone, Idea and Uninor.
Below is the edited transcript of R Chandrashekar, telecom secretary
Q: What are the issues on which the Telecom Commission has sought clarity from the telecom regulator?
A: The Telecom Commission needed additional information or clarity on many issues.
Firstly, The number of slots to be put up for the auction? The TRAI recommended one slot of 5 megahertz for the auction. The commission wants to understand why the TRAI has suggested that only one slot be auctioned even if more spectrum is available.
Secondly, question on the quantum of spectrum, which has been suggested to be kept aside for refarming? Whether all the refarming has to be done at the same time? Or there are other ways of optimizing it. Whether the entire spectrum needs to kept aside now and kept idle till such time that individual licenses expire or it has to be done progressively.
There are questions relating to the pricing of spectrum? Time for relocation of refarmed operators is being proposed? There are a whole set of issues relating to the recommendations with regard to refarming, which have been raised. On modalities there are many points where clarification is necessary.
Thirdly, issues relating to pricing. For example the reserve price, which has been fixed, the assumptions and the basis of that reserve price, the suggestion with regard to the spectrum usage charges, the installment payment plan, which has been suggested and the overall impact of this package in terms of tariffs and revenue.
Also, there have been a number of issues raised by the operators in representations that they made to the government and to the regulator. Points relating to rollout and the eligibility of old and new bidders and the caps and how much of spectrum telecom operators will would be eligible.
Q: The telecom regulators recommendations had justified a high reserve price on the basis of liberalisation of spectrum. Did the commission find this justification in correct, correct, what were the views?
A: This is not the stage at which the commission would come to a conclusion on whether this is or is not the appropriate reserve price. This is the stage at which we are trying to understand the basis of the TRAI’s recommendation and what exactly were the calculations and assumptions that have been made. It is true that some of the main assumptions and basis are contained in the report but it’s also a fact that certain additional inputs as well as different kinds of analysis have been brought out in some of the representations that have been received. All of these are being further referred to the TRAI for their comments on the points that have been made.
Q: What is the view of the department of telecommunications when it comes to this reserve price issue?
A: The department of telecommunications will have to take a final call on these issues, at a certain point in time. We are not at this stage now.
What we making sure that we have all the necessary inputs and analysis, so that, when we take a final call and make a recommendation on what should be the reserve price, what should be the approach towards the auction or the number of slots or reforming - then all of these inputs are taken into account.
At this stage we are seeking further inputs from the TRAI. Procedurally, it is necessary for the government to actually make a reference to the TRAI on points where additional information is required or there is different view before taking a final decision. Once the TRAI’s final recommendations are out, then we will take a final view.
May 18 2013, 17:26
- in MARKET OUTLOOK
May 17 2013, 12:39
- in MARKET OUTLOOK