• Quotes

  • NAVs

  • News

  • Messages

  • Opinions

  • Notices

  • Videos

Search: Messages    Stock    Boarder
 
Post a Message | Explore Forums  |  Browse Stock Messages  |  Hot Discussions  | Top rated Messages  | Top Boarders
Moneycontrol >> Messageboard >> Stocks >> Tata Steel
   You are here :     Moneycontrol     MMB   Stocks   Tata Steel

Tata Steel

Belongs to: Steel - Large
BSE: 500470
NSE: TATASTEEL
233.75  -13.3 (-5.38)
Volume: 10024540
What is your trading strategy on Tata Steel?
  Buy     Sell     Hold     
Buy
 66%
Sell
 27%
Hold
 7%
Total no. of Votes : 217  
Buy, Sell or Hold? 265 comments
2 positive opinions
8 negative opinions
11 boarder queries
281 boarder tracking
Peer stocks in Steel - Large sector
View by:
Latest Messages
Most Active
Top Rated
Top Tracked
07 Jan 2009 18:22

14% Sales drop - Q3

Posted by : vkk43
Price when posted : BSE: Rs 233.65 ( -5.31 % ), NSE: Rs. 233.75 ( -5.38 % )
View full thread (5 messages)

Tracked by: 0 Boarder

I too feel so. Thanks....

In reply to:

14% Sales drop - Q3

Posted by : vkeykey

At 185/- it is a great BUY.

07 Jan 2009 17:47

weak

Posted by : vkk43
Price when posted : BSE: Rs 233.65 ( -5.31 % ), NSE: Rs. 233.75 ( -5.38 % )
View full thread (1 messages)

Tracked by: 0 Boarder

The undertone of the share has turned weak today....

07 Jan 2009 15:07

get out of Tata Steel

Posted by : marketbear
Price when posted : BSE: Rs 232.50 ( -5.78 % ), NSE: Rs. 234.00 ( -5.28 % )
View full thread (3 messages)

Tracked by: 0 Boarder

below 235 Tata Steel is turning weak now and can close below 230 level today itself....

In reply to:

get out of Tata Steel

Posted by : shivabhash

dear marketbear, how true was u r advice regarding tata steel.. hats off to u..fallan to 229..less..regards

07 Jan 2009 15:00

get out of Tata Steel

Posted by : shivabhash
Price when posted : BSE: Rs 238.50 ( -3.34 % ), NSE: Rs. 231.90 ( -6.13 % )
View full thread (3 messages)

Tracked by: 0 Boarder

dear marketbear, how true was u r advice regarding tata steel.. hats off to u..fallan to 229..less..regards...

In reply to:

get out of Tata Steel

Posted by : marketbear

People are adviced to get out of Tata Steel as stock will follow the market trend in coming days and further weakness in the market will be lead by metals who are rather outperforming the markets.

07 Jan 2009 14:23

get out of Tata Steel

Posted by : marketbear
Price when posted : BSE: Rs 237.70 ( -3.67 % ), NSE: Rs. 240.00 ( -2.85 % )
View full thread (3 messages)

Tracked by: 0 Boarder

People are adviced to get out of Tata Steel as stock will follow the market trend in coming days and further weakness in the market will be lead by metals who are rather outperforming the markets....

07 Jan 2009 10:07

Don`t sell

Posted by : Cool Bull
Price when posted : BSE: Rs 252.70 ( 2.41 % ), NSE: Rs. 254.50 ( 3.02 % )
View full thread (4 messages)

Tracked by: 0 Boarder

You can`t compare ISPAT with Tata Steel. They are poles apart in financial matters....

In reply to:

Don`t sell

Posted by : Guest

my view,

1. TATA + corus deal has added lot of burden on TATA steel. The interest burden is huge.
(there was article on ISPAT India 5th largest steel company that its asking government for corporate debt same is the case here lot of interest to pay)
2. Steel industry is going thru rough patch less production-less sale-less profit....beleive me this will carry on for the next quarter too.

i think even at 212 its very bad buy. we shuld think abt buying only in next quarter where new infra projects may help these.


06 Jan 2009 22:38

Don`t sell

Posted by : Guest
Price when posted : BSE: Rs 246.75 ( 0.67 % ), NSE: Rs. 247.05 ( 0.59 % )
View full thread (4 messages)

Tracked by: 0 Boarder

my view,

1. TATA + corus deal has added lot of burden on TATA steel. The interest burden is huge.
(there was article on ISPAT India 5th largest steel company that its asking government for corporate debt same is the case here lot of interest to pay)
2. Steel industry is going thru rough patch less production-less sale-less profit....beleive me this will carry on for the next quarter too.

i think even at 212 its very bad buy. we shuld think abt buying only in next quarter where new infra projects may help these.


...

In reply to:

Don`t sell

Posted by : rk_singal

My view is tisco has the potential to go up, provided it gets fundings for chorus operations, so it can be a best buy at 212 levels or so.

06 Jan 2009 22:21

14% Sales drop - Q3

Posted by : vkeykey
Price when posted : BSE: Rs 246.75 ( 0.67 % ), NSE: Rs. 247.05 ( 0.59 % )
View full thread (5 messages)

Tracked by: 0 Boarder

At 185/- it is a great BUY....

In reply to:

14% Sales drop - Q3

Posted by : CGRK

Tata Steel may give us a chance for re-entry around 200, even 185 level cannot be ruled out. My inferences are based on the following:-
1. The weak demand and pricing environment prevailing in the steel sector will affect Tata Steel`s cash accruals over the short-medium term.
2. The strain on the company`s financial flexibility and capital structure because of ongoing capital expenditure.
3. Acquisition of Corus has given Tata Steel geographical diversity and a strong presence in value-added products but whatever gain offset by Corus`s low profitability and the combined entities exposure to end user industries.

06 Jan 2009 22:20

14% Sales drop - Q3

Posted by : CGRK
Price when posted : BSE: Rs 246.75 ( 0.67 % ), NSE: Rs. 247.05 ( 0.59 % )
View full thread (5 messages)

Tracked by: 0 Boarder

Tata Steel may give us a chance for re-entry around 200, even 185 level cannot be ruled out. My inferences are based on the following:-
1. The weak demand and pricing environment prevailing in the steel sector will affect Tata Steel`s cash accruals over the short-medium term.
2. The strain on the company`s financial flexibility and capital structure because of ongoing capital expenditure.
3. Acquisition of Corus has given Tata Steel geographical diversity and a strong presence in value-added products but whatever gain offset by Corus`s low profitability and the combined entities exposure to end user industries....

In reply to:

14% Sales drop - Q3

Posted by : MBMSR

wHAT i intepret from this is INTEREST costs would have risen for inventory holding.

Margins subdued due to poor realisations.

This is a cyclical business when it is good it only gets better & when bad it gets worse at cost up / realiations low .

Hence it will go below 212-200 levles once for a reentry then.
world steel king MITTAL is silent due to extreme stress as STEEL is massive game.

Correct me if any better thought is seen.......

06 Jan 2009 21:48

14% Sales drop - Q3

Posted by : MBMSR
Price when posted : BSE: Rs 246.75 ( 0.67 % ), NSE: Rs. 247.05 ( 0.59 % )
View full thread (5 messages)

Tracked by: 0 Boarder

wHAT i intepret from this is INTEREST costs would have risen for inventory holding.

Margins subdued due to poor realisations.

This is a cyclical business when it is good it only gets better & when bad it gets worse at cost up / realiations low .

Hence it will go below 212-200 levles once for a reentry then.
world steel king MITTAL is silent due to extreme stress as STEEL is massive game.

Correct me if any better thought is seen..........

In reply to:

14% Sales drop - Q3

Posted by : CGRK

The Q3 sales at 1.07 million tons were lower by about 14% as compared to corresponding quarter last year due to current economic slowdown.
However, 27% growth has been registered in the long product sales during the third quarter at 0.48 million tons.
The hot metal production at 1.70 million tons and crude steel production at 1.50 million tons was higher by 23% and 17% respectively as compared to volumes in the same quarter last year.

06 Jan 2009 21:32

14% Sales drop - Q3

Posted by : CGRK
Price when posted : BSE: Rs 246.75 ( 0.67 % ), NSE: Rs. 247.05 ( 0.59 % )
View full thread (5 messages)

Tracked by: 0 Boarder

The Q3 sales at 1.07 million tons were lower by about 14% as compared to corresponding quarter last year due to current economic slowdown.
However, 27% growth has been registered in the long product sales during the third quarter at 0.48 million tons.
The hot metal production at 1.70 million tons and crude steel production at 1.50 million tons was higher by 23% and 17% respectively as compared to volumes in the same quarter last year.

...

06 Jan 2009 20:38

Don`t sell

Posted by : ashu_doc81
Price when posted : BSE: Rs 246.75 ( 0.67 % ), NSE: Rs. 247.05 ( 0.59 % )
View full thread (4 messages)

Tracked by: 0 Boarder

can anyone pls tell me why we are talking about this fall of tisco below 210 level? market is strong now, and there are no future hurdles till elections in april, and we can expect good growth till that time and we can hold it...am I right?...

In reply to:

Don`t sell

Posted by : rk_singal

My view is tisco has the potential to go up, provided it gets fundings for chorus operations, so it can be a best buy at 212 levels or so.

06 Jan 2009 18:26

Don`t sell

Posted by : rk_singal
Price when posted : BSE: Rs 242.90 ( -0.90 % ), NSE: Rs. 247.05 ( 0.59 % )
View full thread (4 messages)

Tracked by: 0 Boarder

My view is tisco has the potential to go up, provided it gets fundings for chorus operations, so it can be a best buy at 212 levels or so....

06 Jan 2009 12:47

book profits

Posted by : shivabhash
Price when posted : BSE: Rs 250.50 ( 2.20 % ), NSE: Rs. 249.75 ( 1.69 % )
View full thread (5 messages)

Tracked by: 0 Boarder

Dear marketbear,thanks,i will hold till 258,for tgt. indicated by.regards....

In reply to:

book profits

Posted by : marketbear

you can hold on the short position atleast for this week. Stop loss can be placed at 258 levels. Stock can come down towards 226 and then 204 level. You can book profits at around 226 level to avoid undue risk.

06 Jan 2009 12:39

book profits

Posted by : marketbear
Price when posted : BSE: Rs 250.60 ( 2.24 % ), NSE: Rs. 250.65 ( 2.06 % )
View full thread (5 messages)

Tracked by: 0 Boarder

you can hold on the short position atleast for this week. Stop loss can be placed at 258 levels. Stock can come down towards 226 and then 204 level. You can book profits at around 226 level to avoid undue risk....

In reply to:

book profits

Posted by : shivabhash

Dear marketbear,i m short on tatasteel @237 lvl.any chance it will turn back from current lvl.248. what is the resistance ..should i hold for the tgt..235,or less. or book loss.if possible guide.regards

Go to page:   1    2    3    4    5    6    Next  [  ]    

Feedback

Boarders Outlook on Tata Steel

 positive outlook
 negative outlook
marketbear  |  CGRK  |  mrfutures
 |  P.MITRA

More from the Steel - Large Sector

JSW Steel  |   SAIL  |   Tata Steel-CCPS  |   Visa Steel

Boarders tracking Tata Steel

NAGARSHETH  |   psrajpoot  |   exterminate  |   SAMRAM  |   dash.n.crash  |   stox & more  |   Guna  |   awagdarikar  |   lataamar  |   durgak  |   tanveerpossible  |   tanveerpossible  |   mkodem  |   jain1432  |   play 2 win
 see more

News Updates on Tata Steel

Tata Steel Q3 PAT seen at Rs 1228 cr: KRChoksey - KRChoksey Research has come out with its earning e...
Reduce Tata Steel, target of Rs 164: Religare - Religare Hichens Harrison Research has recommended...

CNBC TV18 CNN IBN CNBC Awaaz IBN 7 IBN LOKMAT